Remember how I said last week that I was going to repeat the phrase,
“the first four games of the NFL season is each team’s
real preseason nowadays”? Well, I’m going to say it
again in large part because it is so true.
The combined worth of all the teams in the NFL is somewhere between
$35-45 billion and the salary cap for each team is $143.28 million.
It doesn’t seem like a lot to ask for teams that pay out
much money and a league that generates that much income to be
able to hit the ground running at a fairly high level at the start
of each season. Unfortunately, as we are seeing again this year,
the majority of teams are ill-prepared to put out a quality product
in the first two or so weeks. Who does it affect the most? I think
the answer – and it should rather obvious if you consistently
build your fantasy teams the same way each year – is running
backs.
There are those that would have you believe that the new Collective
Bargaining Agreement is severely limiting the ability for coaches
to work with their players as much as they need to and I would
say nowhere is that more obvious around the league than the offensive
line, which requires as much chemistry and teamwork as any group
of players in football. It has become commonplace for quarterbacks
and receivers to work on their routes and timing during the spring
and early summer, but when are running backs working on their
timing with offensive line and, perhaps more importantly, when
are linemen working with each other under game-like conditions?
It’s not happening much in training camp (limited padded
practices) or in the preseason (too much fear of losing a key
player in a “meaningless” game).
From 2010 to 2014, NFL teams rushed for an average of 111 to
114 yards league-wide. Through two games this season, the league
average sits at 106.9 with only four teams that have earned a
positive run-block ranking from Pro Football Focus (Cincinnati,
Tennessee, Miami and Chicago). Last year, only two teams “earned”
a -50 or worse rating in PFF’s run-block scoring (Buffalo
and San Diego). In 2015, 14 teams are on pace to hit that mark
through two games. Of course that pace will not continue, but
point to be made here is that if PFF’s grading reflects
what play-callers are seeing on the field during a game, they
aren’t going to stick with the run very long.
So why should you care about these numbers? In short, if you
made the “mistake” of hitching your wagon to a first-round running
back, there’s a good chance your fantasy team is standing at 1-1
or, more than likely, 0-2. And why am I emphasizing “mistake”,
other than because I like being a bit sarcastic? Because I’ve
said for years that if you want to win fantasy football in September
and early October, draft receivers early and often. But if you
want to win your league’s title, you’ll find a way to build your
team around two stud running backs before it’s all said and done.
While I understand this may not be a truism for many owners in
their leagues, I know it is in just about all of mine and it has
been since I started playing fantasy football. The new reality
– which has actually been the new reality for a few years now
– is that running backs aren’t set up for immediate success anymore.
Much of the blame can be pinned on committee attacks, but I think
just as much blame can be put on the proclivity of most coaches
now to ramp up their main back’s workloads in Weeks 1-4 because
they don’t do it during the preseason.
A number of teams each year talk about featuring a physical,
rush-oriented offense, yet seem willing to abandon that philosophy
at the drop of a hat. Part of the reason for that early on is
a realization that the offensive line lacks the chemistry to make
it all work like they envisioned. As any owner of Marshawn
Lynch (nine of 33), LeSean
McCoy (eight of 32), T.J.
Yeldon (eight of 37) or DeMarco
Murray (six of 21) can tell you this year, watching your running
back get hit and tackled in the backfield time after time can
be an unsettling thing. For some perspective on the number of
“stuffed” runs I just provided for each of the four players I
mentioned, McCoy led the league with “stuffed” runs with 41 (in
312 attempts) in 2014 and Murray was second with 37 (in 392 attempts).
The league average of stuffed runs a season ago was 8.75 percent,
so some basic division skills can tell you pretty quickly that
each of the four backs I mentioned above aren’t getting a lot
of help from their blockers.
I’m coming to the realization that part of the reason why
the NFL is become such a pass-heavy league (especially since the
new CBA was signed) is because teams are now using the first four
weeks of the season to get the run-blocking in order. Some teams
don’t have the personnel for this (or are just more ideally
suited to throw the ball all day) and eventually realize they
need to remain a pass-heavy team. Most teams, however, simply
need more time to get all their new parts working as one up front.
I get it; panic is natural at this time of the year when fantasy
results are matching the optimism you felt on draft day. Before
we all go crazy about the bad run-blocking epidemic, however,
let’s keep in mind that two games is a very small sample
size and teams will improve in this area as the season goes on.
However, it speaks to the point I discussed at the top; the players
and the play-calling tendencies that we are seeing now will not
be anything like what we see in about a month for most of these
teams.
To that end, I want to take a look at 16 teams this week, provide
an overview of what they’ve done so far and discuss generally
where they’ll be in a few weeks. I’m also going to put the number
of returning offensive line starters by each team, but will only
count one as “returning” if he is playing the same position he
was at the end of last year.
The Cardinals probably didn’t expect this kind of balance
right out of the box (especially given how quickly Andre Ellington
was injured), but the fact is they have yet to trail in a game
this season. Furthermore, the Saints and the Bears will likely
be two of the weakest defenses Arizona will face all season.
Outlook for October and beyond -
The likely return of LG Mike Iupati this week against the 49ers
should further boost what’s been a surprisingly efficient ground
game thus far (4.4 YPC). However, there’s not a lot of evidence
to suggest that HC Bruce Arians will maintain this level of run-pass
balance much longer as only four of his previous 11 offenses as
an offensive coordinator or head coach have finished in the top
half of the league in rushing attempts. Unsurprisingly, the same
number (four of 11) of his previous offenses have finished in
the top half of the league in rushing. Arians hasn’t had a running
back top 700 rushing yards since Vick
Ballard in 2012 or a 1,000-yard rusher since Rashard Mendenhall
in 2009, so look for this offense to start changing its stripes
as the competition gets more difficult.
Atlanta – 57 rush attempts, 80 pass
attempts (Returning offensive line starters: 2)
OC Kyle Shanahan has shown a tendency to feature his top weapon
at just about every stop in his NFL career and things don’t appear
to be changing in his first season with the Falcons. Julio
Jones is tied with Emmanuel
Sanders for the second-most targets in the league (26) – a
total that is just three shy of the number of rushing attempts
rookie Tevin
Coleman has.
Outlook for October and beyond - Shanahan has a well-earned
reputation as a run-game guru, but many people forget that he
was the play-caller for Houston in 2009 when the Texans led the
league in passing. The talent on the offensive line is such that
we probably shouldn’t expect the running game to perform
much better than it currently is (2.8 YPC), although natural improvement
should be expected from players such as LT Jake Matthews and LG
Andy Levitre since neither one has any prior experience in Shanahan’s
offensive system. It seems reasonable (and sensible) to believe
that Atlanta will maintain its pass-heavy ways as we move forward.
First of all, the Ravens’ returning offensive line starters
stat is a bit misleading since neither regular LT Eugene Monroe
nor RT Ricky Wagner were able to finish last season, which forced
RG Marshal Yanda to kick out to right tackle. Otherwise, Baltimore’s
offensive line looks exactly the same to start this season as
it did at the start of 2014. As far as the pass–run balance,
there will be those that say that OC Marc Trestman’s passing-game
influence is the reason for such an imbalance, although I think
it is a bit of an anomaly given the type of games the Ravens have
been in and kind of matchups they have seen so far. No play-caller
in his right mind is going to dial up 14.5 more pass attempts
per game with the passing-game personnel Baltimore currently has.
Outlook for October and beyond - As far as I’m concerned,
Baltimore is still a running team and will get back to that over
the next week or two; HC John Harbaugh is too good of a coach
to allow his team to get sucked in to a pass-heavy mentality.
Somewhat surprisingly, the Ravens are averaging 3.8 YPC as a team
(4.5 last year) after being projected to be one of the better
running teams in the league this season. I believe this goes to
show that even when there is some carryover along the offensive
line, it still takes a while for the group to gel when they don’t
play a ton of snaps together in the preseason. This team will
run the ball well eventually; the bigger question is whether or
not Justin Forsett will be splitting a significant amount of snaps
with Lorenzo Taliaferro.
The Bills offensive attack is matching
expectations.
A season after sporting what many considered one of the worst
offensive lines in the league, the Bills are averaging a league-high
4.9 YPC, which goes to show you the combined effect that a run
threat at quarterback and small sample size can have on that stat.
Furthermore, neither Indianapolis nor New England is likely going
to field a top run defense in 2015. It also helps matters that
Buffalo has had its top five linemen on the field together for
all but one play the season.
Outlook for October and beyond - Owners knew going into
the season that volume was not going to be a problem for the Bills
and there’s really no reason to expect their current run-pass
ratio to change going forward. In what will be a rarity in this
piece, I think what you see with Buffalo right now is what you
are going to get moving forward as well.
The Panthers have benefited greatly from game flow and playing
two teams with very suspect offenses thus far, neither of which
could apparently make them pay for having an inaccurate quarterback
whose best attribute is his ability to run and a receiver corps
that is among the worst of the league. Carolina goes into its
Week 5 bye playing against the Saints and Bucs over the next two
weeks, so there is an outside shot the offense is going to continue
looking better than it actually is.
Outlook for October and beyond -
Amazingly, not a single one of the Panthers’ first seven opponents
has a win yet. Obviously, that’s going to change soon. Carolina
is set up for success defensively, which will play well into its
ability to continue to stick with the run. However, the Panthers
are not set up for consistent success offensively and that is
going to start becoming apparent very soon. There are only a handful
of quarterbacks in the league that can overcome the combination
of league-average (or worse) receivers and a below-average offensive
line and Cam
Newton is not one of those quarterbacks. If there ever was
a team that can start out 4-0 and then fail to make the playoffs,
this is the kind of team that is set up to do that. There is a
complete lack of talent all across the offensive depth chart behind
the starters and some would argue there isn’t a lot of talent
in the starting lineup either after Newton, Jonathan
Stewart and Greg
Olsen. If I own any Panthers outside of Olsen, I would be
quickly try to move Newton and Stewart while they’re both still
healthy. The Carolina offense we’ve seen so far is the same offense
that were going to continue to see going forward; the Panthers
simply lack the personnel to throw the ball more often.
Chicago – 61 rush attempts, 68 pass
attempts (Returning offensive line starters: 2)
Perhaps the most discouraging thing going on with the Bears is
the reported “pitch count” they intend to keep Matt
Forte on this season. His workload to this point has been
partly a function of injuries to Alshon
Jeffery, Eddie
Royal and Jay
Cutler. Then again, fantasy owners are probably plenty happy
with 19 touches for 105 total yards on a bad day like he had during
a Week 2 blowout against Arizona. As stated earlier, Chicago is
one of four teams that has earned a positive run-blocking grade
from PFF so far. Of course, running ball is a little easier to
do in low-pressure situations that come as a result of the defense
giving up 39.5 points per game.
Outlook for October and beyond - We’re going to learn
a lot about the Bears’ offense in the next four games leading
up to their bye in Week 7. Cutler is expected to miss this week
in Seattle and next week at home against Oakland before returning
for road games at Kansas City and Detroit. The Seahawks and Chiefs
have the personnel to shut down a one-dimensional offensive attack
and one could argue the Raiders just got done slowing down a similar
offense last week when they beat Baltimore. Chicago is going to
strive for balance because that’s what the majority of HC
John Fox’s teams do, but the combination of Forte’s
age (30 in December), reduced snaps (down from the 93 percent
he saw a season ago) and number of injuries the Bears are starting
to incur may end up conspiring to turn him into the low-end RB1
I feared he would be at the beginning of the season. As such,
I don’t see Forte maintaining his current pace - whether
that comes as a result of apathy or injury.
All seemed right in the world in Week 1 as Jeremy Hill owners
got two touchdowns and Giovani Bernard owners saw the change-of-pace
back receive 14 touches. Then Week 2 happened (Hill had two fumbles,
Bernard recorded his second career 100-yard rushing game), perhaps
feeding the fire that Bernard’s role could be more than
just complementary this year. At least the Bengals can lay claim
to PFF’s best run-blocking grade through two contests (5.6).
Outlook for October and beyond -
This is been one of those few cases around the league where the
offensive line has played well, but the main running back has
left us wanting for more. I think the majority of fantasy owners
realize that Hill is probably more the back that averaged 5.1
YPC as a rookie and not the one that’s averaging 3.5 through two
games. OC Hue Jackson has long favored a power-running attack,
so one would have to think unless Hill’s fumbling issues become
a regular occurrence, he’s going to go right back to the high-volume
back he was expected to be in the early-to-mid second round of
most drafts. With his effort the first two games, Bernard has
played himself into more than just a complementary role, although
I’m fairly certain he won’t exceed last year’s pace – 211 touches
in 13 games – by much, assuming he can stay healthy.
Like Buffalo, this is another extreme case of a team trying to
hide a quarterback. It’s really anybody’s guess as
to what the Browns are doing with their running backs, however,
as Isaiah Crowell and rookie Duke Johnson are both plugging along
at 3.4 YPC behind what is supposed to be one of the better offense
of lines in the NFL. Perhaps the most surprising thing is that
Johnson, who was supposed to take on the Giovani Bernard role
in this offense, hasn’t even seen a target in the passing
game.
Outlook for October and beyond - There has been some talk
that ex-Seahawk Robert Turbin is going to take over the lead-back
role in this offense once he returns from a high-ankle sprain
and, quite frankly, I wouldn’t be surprised if that ends
up being the case. To be fair, one of the Browns’ two games
thus far was against the Jets, who possess a stellar run defense,
so it seems a bit harsh to make a quick judgment here when Cleveland
has played one “normal” opponent. With that said,
the return of Josh McCown to the starting lineup does not bode
well for the running game going forward as it removes the run
threat of Johnny Manziel at quarterback and probably reduces the
likelihood that Travis Benjamin can stretch out defenses. Making
matters worse, Cleveland faces a rather difficult stretch of run
defenses between now and its Week 11 bye. In short, I don’t
see this situation getting any better and, quite frankly, I can
see it getting much worse.
For those folks hoping and believing the Cowboys’ all-world
offensive line was going to make a star out of any running back,
let’s just say it’s not looking very good right now.
Joseph Randle is averaging 3.4 YPC, Darren McFadden is at 2.9
and Dallas has yet to rush for a touchdown. It seems highly unlikely
any of that production is going to get any better considering
the long-term injuries to Tony Romo and Dez Bryant.
Outlook for October and beyond -Brandon Weeden is not
suited to be a multi-week starting quarterback, Terrance Williams
is very much stretched as a lead receiver and TE Jason Witten
is dealing with a variety of ankle and knee sprains. It’s
not really fair to ask Dallas to overcome the number of injuries
has already suffered to its skill positions because I’m
not sure there’s a team in the league that could. I suspect
in the two or so months that Weeden or Matt Cassel is under center,
the Cowboys will lean much heavier on the run than they have so
far. (Remember, Dallas had a 508-476 run-to-pass ratio last year
and that was with a mostly healthy Romo and a healthy Bryant.)
As far as I’m concerned, the only thing the Cowboys’
running game has going for it now is potential volume. Given the
workload split so far, Randle and Lance Dunbar are probably no
better than low-end flex options moving forward while McFadden
can probably be dropped in most leagues. Given their current injury
situation, the Cowboys will be hard-pressed to consistently produce
more than one fantasy-relevant player each week.
In retrospect, it should have been fairly obvious the transition
from the style of offense Peyton Manning has run for so many years
to HC Gary Kubiak’s scheme was going to be an ugly one at
first. Most people also realized the Broncos’ offensive
line was going to be a work in progress. The majority of people
– myself included – figured between the pairing of
Kubiak and OC Rick Dennison, each of whom has overseen the development
of a number of very good zone-blocking offense of lines in their
day (usually working together), would be able to whip up a cohesive
front five by the start of the season. That clearly has not happened,
as Denver’s team run-blocking score is -18.8 per PFF –
second-worst in the league (Tampa Bay, -28).
Outlook for October and beyond - One of the craziest things
I’ve heard and/or read over the first two weeks of the season
is that Ronnie Hillman is running better than C.J. Anderson. What
those people mean is that Hillman has a better YPC (3.6 vs. Anderson’s
2.3) because as the run-blocking score above will tell you, neither
runner is getting much help up front. Nineteen of Denver’s
47 rush attempts (40.4 percent) have been for no gain or negative
yardage, so let’s call it what is – bad blocking.
Kubiak and Dennison have far too good of a track record for this
running game to be stuck in the mud for much longer and the upcoming
schedule would seem to be just the thing the Broncos need to get
it rolling. Each of their next four opponents rank 20th or worse
against the run.
Detroit – 32 rush attempts, 83 pass
attempts (Returning offensive line starters: 3)
Let me get this right: the Lions spend their first two draft
picks (LG Laken Tomlinson and RB Ameer Abdullah) on improving
the running game and decide to run the ball an average of 16 times?
It’s an approach that would make some sense if the first
two opponents are the Bills and the Jets, but I’m not sure
it is all that logical against the Chargers and Vikings. While
it should be noted the Lions trailed all game against Minnesota
last week, they held the lead for three-plus quarters versus San
Diego in the opener, so game flow has not dictated such a crazy
pass-run ratio.
Outlook for October and beyond - I’m not really not
sure what we can conclude at this point. There’s little
doubt that Abdullah is the best pure (and most explosive) runner
Detroit has, but I’m not sure it matters when the most carries
any Lions’ running back has in a game through two weeks
is seven. I wouldn’t be too concerned about the No. 54 overall
pick quite yet, although I know I’d be asking myself if
I’m a Lions’ fan why Abdullah had seven touches versus
six apiece for Joique Bell and Theo Riddick last week. Unfortunately,
I think it is going take a bit of time before owners will start
experiencing the joys of owning the rookie since Denver, Seattle
and Arizona are the next teams up on Detroit’s schedule.
Green Bay – 59 rush attempts, 56
pass attempts (Returning offensive line starters: 4)
The Packers’ run-blocking score (-11.6) per PFF is actually
worse than the Lions (-9.7), although one might be hard-pressed
to tell since they are averaging 4.4 YPC and 130 rushing yards
as a team. It’s important to note that new OC Tom Clements
is calling the plays now as opposed to HC Mike McCarthy, but this
offense looks pretty much the same thus far as the ones we have
grown accustomed to from McCarthy.
Outlook for October and beyond - Green Bay simply does
not turn the ball over very much, so it rarely ever needs to go
in full-blown pass mode or take many low-percentage chances. In
fact, I’d say the riskiest thing about this offense is the
physical nature with which Eddie Lacy runs, because defenses have
no choice but to respect Aaron Rodgers’ ability to beat
them deep. What you’ve seen thus far from the Packers is
probably what you’re going to get the rest of the season.
Meet the NFL’s leader in pass attempts. If you want to
talk about “finding an identity”, look no further
than the Texans, who have no business averaging 52.5 throws with
Brian Hoyer and Ryan Mallett at quarterback. (Unsurprisingly,
Houston ranks last in team completion percentage at 50.5.) Much
of that disparity can be blamed on the absence of Arian Foster,
but this kind of imbalance without him around also suggests HC
Bill O’Brien never had any faith in his backup running backs.
Outlook for October and beyond - Owners looking for a bit
of silver lining will be happy to know the Texans’ first
two opponents (Kansas City and Carolina) may end up being good
defenses when all is said and done. Furthermore, when Foster makes
his return – likely in Week 4 – Houston can get back
to what it does well and figures to face a number of average to
below-average run defenses over the remainder of the schedule.
I’d be lying, however, if I said the lack of running-game
success without Foster wasn’t at least a little bit concerning,
especially since the Panthers were without MLB Luke Kuechly and
DT Star Lotulelei last week. With that said, Foster’s return
should serve as a huge boon to the running and passing attacks.
Indianapolis – 41 rush attempts,
86 pass attempts (Returning offensive line starters: 3)
Andrew Luck has been pressured on 38 of his 94 drop-backs so
far the season. Time isn’t going to allow me to take note
how many of those throws were more than 10 yards downfield, but
PFF has charted Luck with 12 attempts when intended target was
more than 20 yards down the field. I’d be stunned if most
of those 12 attempts weren’t also against the blitz. So
why do you care? It’s one thing if a team decides to bring
in a 32-year-old running back and wants to monitor his touches
early in the season. It’s another thing for a team to know
that it has an inexperienced (at best) or below-average offensive
line and to ask their quarterback to chuck it down the field when
the more prudent move would be to throw more often to the running
backs (perhaps a screen every now and then?) or hit the possession
receiver over the middle a few more times.
Outlook for October and beyond - Fortunately for owners
of Luck and just about every other fantasy-viable Colt, the worst
part of the season should be over. Much like Houston’s complete
disregard for the running game without Foster, Indianapolis’
apparent indifference in protecting Luck via upgrading his offensive
line or through play-calling is perplexing. The next three opponents
are all inside what figures to be the worst division in football
(the AFC South), so Indianapolis has a chance to get itself righted
and figure out how it’s going to correct its protection
problems before it faces New England (Week 6), Carolina (Week
8) and Denver (Week 9) next month. And please do me a favor, loyal
readers: can we table the talk about Andre Johnson being done
until after the Colts face some non-Jet and Bill defenses? Separation
was a problem for him last year and he caught 85 passes. Let’s
not pretend like you know after two games one season later that
a future Hall of Famer is ready to be put out to pasture. Anquan
Boldin hasn’t created separation consistently for at least
three years and continues to be an 80-catch player in the NFL.
The Jaguars’ run-blocking graded out as the eighth-worst
in 2014, so it’s a refreshing change to see they are ranked
as the eighth-best so far this season. Having a good running back
helps in that regard, although it is a bit troubling that Yeldon
is averaging 3.3 YPC thus far. It’ll be interesting to see
if those numbers change much over the next two weeks as Jacksonville
hits the road to face New England and Indianapolis, two teams
who have struggled to stop the run but have the kind of explosive
offenses that can force teams out of their comfort zone.
Outlook for October and beyond - I think a strong case
can be made the Jaguars’ win last week over the Dolphins
was perhaps the most impressive one in two-plus seasons under
HC Gus Bradley. There is tangible progress being made in Jacksonville
and it should only get better once TE Julius Thomas returns from
injury. With that said, the Jaguars’ margin for error is
still much thinner than it is for most teams – something
I expect to become quite obvious as they play their three games
on the road – so they need to remain committed to the run
in order to set up the passing game regardless of whether or not
they fall behind quickly or not.
Kansas City – 61 rush attempts, 58
pass attempts (Returning offensive line starters: 0)
Alex Smith probably enjoys more job security than any average
quarterback in recent memory. There’s something to be said
about a quarterback that puts such a high priority on taking care
of the ball, but I wait for the day when a defensive coordinator
does the unthinkable and puts all 11 men within 10-15 yards of
the line of scrimmage on every play because Smith simply refuses
to put safeties on their heels. As a result, it’s hard for
Travis Kelce and Jeremy Maclin to maximize their talents to stretch
the field and speaks to the greatness of Jamaal Charles that he
can average 4.9 YPC behind a completely rebuilt line and do it
against opponents that don’t have to respect the deep ball.
Outlook for October and beyond - It seems like a pretty
good bet the Kansas City offense you see now is going to be the
same one you see at the end of the season, barring injury. Charles
hasn’t had one of those 2-3 games per year yet where Reid
seems to forget about him, although it is fair to wonder if one
is coming after his two-fumble performance in Week 2, which may
provide a convenient excuse to lighten the load on Charles early
in the season as the Chiefs suggested they would do this summer.
Otherwise, I expect business as usual in KC.
Doug Orth has written for FF
Today since 2006 and been featured in USA Today’s Fantasy
Football Preview magazine since 2010. He hosted USA Today’s
hour-long, pre-kickoff fantasy football internet chat every Sunday
in 2012-13 and appears as a guest analyst on a number of national
sports radio shows, including Sirius XM’s “Fantasy Drive”.
Doug is also a member of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association.