Preseason Schedule Analysis
6/28/11
In these lockout-induced times, it may seem a bit premature to forecast
players for 2011. After all, what is the upside of taking a late
June snapshot at teams and players when there is likely to be nearly
500 free agents hit the market once owners and player finally settle
on a new Collective Bargaining Agreement?
The question has merit, but it may ease your mind fantasy football
is often a matter of interpreting a series of snapshots because
it is the lone major professional sport that is typically played
just once a week. (In other words, owners are faced with the dilemma
of determining whether a Week 1 stud is worth starting over a
more proven player in Week 2. In the other sports, one poor performance
doesn’t necessarily ruin a player’s entire week.)
We are all aware of the fact the landscape of the NFL is constantly
changing, so one of my jobs as a fantasy football analyst is to
provide a baseline for which to build a knowledge base for the
upcoming season. The most natural place to start that process
is with the incoming rookie class because it is guaranteed to
shuffle the fantasy football playing deck every year.
With that said, a good part of the preparation process every
summer is trying to figure out just how much impact the newcomers
can have in fantasy for the upcoming season. In most cases, running
backs steal the show when it comes to immediate contributions,
although that notion has been challenged in recent years by the
rookie campaigns of players such as Matt Ryan, Sam Bradford, Hakeem
Nicks, Dez Bryant, Aaron Hernandez and Rob Gronkowski. Even the
notion that a rookie who goes through a long holdout cannot be
productive in his first year has taken a beating by the likes
of Michael Crabtree. However, owners can start their path to fantasy
glory every year by asking themselves a few questions when it
comes to rookie evaluation for fantasy purposes:
- Is he in a position to succeed?
For a RB, does he have a good line to run behind and an OC that
likes to run the ball? For a QB, does he have a good pass-blocking
line and 2-3 decent options in the passing game? For a WR or
TE, does he have a good QB throwing him the ball? Does he operate
opposite a star WR or is he being counted on to carry the passing
game?
- Is he an offensive building block,
complementary piece or role player?
- Does his "style" fit in
the team's offense? (Unfortunately, we can’t take
for granted that teams and their personnel departments do this.)
For example, does Mark Ingram’s power and vision fit into
New Orleans’ pass-heavy offensive scheme? Does Julio Jones
possess enough eye-popping talent to find an immediate fantasy-worthy
niche in Atlanta? Does Daniel Thomas bring something new to
the Miami backfield or is he just a younger Ronnie Brown? Does
A.J. Green’s natural talent allow him to assume WR1 duties
right away in Cincinnati? Does Jonathan Baldwin’s size
and speed mean instant success in the run-oriented Chiefs’
offense? Was Baldwin trapped in a no-win situation in college
and were his work-ethic and character concerns overblown? Or
will Chiefs HC Todd Haley be forced to “break him down”
in the same way he did Dwayne Bowe in order to get him to fall
in line?
Certainly, there are more questions that can be asked, but to
establish a baseline on a rookie, I think this gives us a pretty
good start. At the very least, I hope to provide each of you my
initial assessments on the incoming class (complete with player
strengths and weaknesses) before I really buckle down on player
evaluations next month with the release of the first round of
PSAs.
Note: The rankings below are for the 2011 season only and
are ranked in order of likelihood of fantasy impact. (For example,
QBs like Christian Ponder or Andy Dalton may accrue more fantasy
points given their position, but the chances of them impacting
a fantasy team are slimmer than say, a potential fantasy WR3 in
a three-WR league, because the WR could be an every-week starter.)
Players who just missed the cut (in no
particular order):
- Austin
Pettis, WR St. Louis - Barring a potential Plaxico Burress
signing, Pettis has a good shot at carving out a role as the
Rams' best red-zone threat right away. Should Mark Clayton,
Laurent Robinson and/or Donnie Avery each fall victim to injury
again, Pettis could have fairly significant fantasy value as
a big, sure-handed possession receiver in his rookie season.
- Randall
Cobb, WR Green Bay - In the Packers' potent passing attack,
even a WR4 can possess some fantasy value. The pathway to Cobb's
fantasy success is littered with obstacles at the moment, but
it isn't unreasonable to think James Jones will leave via free
agency and Donald Driver's production takes another step back
this season.
- Vincent
Brown, WR San Diego - Much like Cobb, Brown's pathway appears
blocked at the moment with Vincent Jackson, Malcom Floyd and
Patrick Crayton likely locked in as the top three receivers
in San Diego. However, the Chargers seemingly needed duct tape
and bailing wire to hold this receiving corps together last
season because of injuries and holdouts.
- Colin
Kaepernick, QB San Francisco - If Kaepernick is able to
beat out Alex Smith in training camp or early in the season,
the rookie's running ability could boost Frank Gore's numbers
in much the same way Michael Vick did for LeSean McCoy (or Vince
Young for Chris Johnson). Also, bear in mind that Kaepernick
would have the benefit of throwing the ball to Vernon Davis
and Michael Crabtree.
- Tandon
Doss, WR Baltimore - Possessing the same kind of skill set
of the receiver he is likely to replace (T.J. Houshmandzadeh),
Doss may be the team's first option should Derrick Mason finally
start showing his age. In a PPR league, Doss could easily have
more value than a player selected two rounds ahead of him (Torrey
Smith). It's also notable that QB Joe Flacco pushed for Doss'
selection.
- Blaine
Gabbert, QB Jacksonville - Each day the lockout continues,
the chances that rookie QBs like Kaepernick and Gabbert start
in 2011 decrease a bit more. David Garrard is coming off one
of his best seasons, but the Jags didn't trade up to select
the Missouri signal-caller just for roster depth. While Gabbert
is likely a year away from a meaningful contribution, Jacksonville
won't hesitate to turn to him if Garrard slips this season.
- Cecil
Shorts, WR Jacksonville - This Mount Union product is expected
to compete with Jarrett Dillard for the WR3 slot as a Jag right
away. With Mike Sims-Walker almost certainly out the door and
Jason Hill far from entrenched as the WR2 opposite Mike Thomas,
it is not inconceivable that Shorts earns a starting job before
the end of the season.
- Baron
Batch, RB Pittsburgh - The likely replacement for Mewelde
Moore, Batch may need to fend off veteran competition (thanks
to the lockout) such as Tiki Barber or Brandon Jackson in order
to capture a third-down role with the Steelers. While Rashard
Mendenhall does most of the heavy lifting in Pittsburgh's backfield,
Moore has carved out some usefulness in deep leagues over the
years; Batch could easily do the same.
- Robert
Housler, TE Arizona - For the first time in years, Arizona
has a potential pass-catching threat at TE. Bear in mind that
while Arizona's passing game figures to remain receiver-oriented,
most of the Cardinals' likely QB options will embrace the idea
of occasionally hitting Housler down the field against a linebacker
or safety as opposed to threading the needle to a double-covered
Larry Fitzgerald.
- Jacquizz
Rodgers, RB Atlanta - A few things need to happen in order
for Rodgers to have a chance at establishing PPR value this
season (most notably Jason Snelling choosing to leave as a free
agent), but it is not out of the question that Rodgers succeeds
where Jerious Norwood failed and can remain durable enough to
delay Michael Turner's slow but steady decline.
- Kyle
Rudolph, TE Minnesota - With Visanthe Shiancoe around to
steal much of his thunder in 2011, I debated whether or not
to put the draft's best all-around tight end on the honorable
mention list. Ultimately, I fully expect a young QB like Ponder
to lean on his TEs early on in his career, particularly if Sidney
Rice leaves via free agency and is not replaced with a comparable
receiver.
Additional rookies who warrant consideration
(depending on a number of factors, including injured veterans, free
agency or potential holdouts): Jamie
Harper, RB Tennessee; Jerrel
Jernigan, WR NY Giants; Bilal
Powell, RB NY Jets; Virgil
Green, TE Denver; Delone
Carter, RB Indianapolis; Shane
Vereen, RB New England; Ronald
Johnson, WR San Francisco; Aldrick
Robinson, WR Washington
20.
Jake Locker, QB Tennessee
Locker's value hinges on the "type"
of free agent QB Tennessee signs.
Reasons to like Locker: In terms
of the makeup of a college QB entering the NFL, it’s hard to knock
Locker for most of the qualities he brings to the table. At 6-3
and 230 pounds, Locker already has a good build for a NFL quarterback.
And as one might expect from a player considered a five-tool outfielder
in baseball, Locker will enter the league as one of the best athletes
at his position and possibly possess one of the NFL’s strongest
arms. Although he passed up the opportunity to enter the 2010
NFL draft and possibly a higher draft slot, Locker likely made
the right professional choice to stay in college through his senior
year in order to spend one more year in HC Steve Sarkisian’s pro-style
attack and give him one more year to address the flaws in his
game. In addition to being a four-year starter, it’s hard to find
an opposing coach who doesn’t believe in Locker’s intangibles,
ability and/or leadership qualities. While there is still plenty
of work for him to do with his mechanics – most notably his footwork
and pocket presence – Locker will get the opportunity to work
with OC Chris Palmer, who has helped develop young QBs like Eli
Manning and Tony
Romo over the last several years. It is also noteworthy that
Locker will have the support of one of the league’s most gifted
RBs in Chris Johnson, which should mean the rookie gets a chance
to ease into his role a bit more than the average first-year QB.
Reasons to dislike Locker: One
big concern seems to override all the other positives Locker possesses:
accuracy inside the pocket – a pretty notable concern for any
QB, rookie or veteran. (Why did I specify “inside the pocket”?
Because depending on the source, Locker’s completion percentage
outside the pocket in college was 70%. So, is this accuracy problem
inside the pocket a mental obstacle or something that is the byproduct
of being a “running quarterback” for most of his career with just
two years of experience in a pro-style attack?). Like many other
strong-armed QBs, Locker knows he has a cannon and, as a result,
will try to fit throws into windows that don’t always exist. Given
his prowess as a runner and solid build, it’s not surprising Locker
had to be reigned back by his college coaches because his willingness
to challenge tacklers in an effort to gain extra yardage led to
some unnecessary injuries throughout his college career. And because
he is a two-sport star – he was drafted by the Los Angeles Angels
of Anaheim in 2010 and received a $300 K bonus from them – questions
about his commitment to football will linger as long as he has
any association with the Angels, although he has passed on a number
of opportunities already to commit to baseball full-time.
Fantasy Assessment: The pre-draft
opinions on Locker were all over the board; some “rogue” scouts
compared him to a young Brett
Favre or Jay
Cutler (strong but erratic arm, good runner and great athlete
who had to carry his college team) while others had him pegged
as a second- or third-round talent because his completion percentage
at the University of Washington was 54% - very low by today’s
standards for a blue-chip QB. I’m going to go in a slightly different
direction – I believe Tennessee wanted a QB similar to Vince Young
(incredible athlete even if the accuracy is a bit questionable
to start) but with none of the headaches he caused the team. Locker
is a bit of a wild-card to include on this list given the likelihood
that Tennessee will bring in a veteran to compete with him. For
example, if the free agent is someone at the level of a Matt
Hasselbeck, then Locker may only see the field sporadically
in his rookie season. But if the team’s idea of competition is
bringing back Kerry
Collins and Rusty
Smith, then Locker has some low-end fantasy QB2 potential
in 12-team leagues this season, in large part due to his running
ability. Even though the Titans’ offense will continue to be centered
on Johnson, they possess more offensive talent than most casual
observers realize. WR Kenny
Britt– if he can ever stay out of trouble– has WR1 ability
and TE Jared
Cook may finally be ready to capitalize on his potential after
completing a strong run to finish the 2010 season.
Fearless late-June prediction (12 starts):
190-of-335 for 2300 yards, 11 TD and 14 INT; 60 rushes, 330 yards
and two rushing TDs
19.
Kendall Hunter, RB San Francisco
Reasons to like Hunter: A three-year
starter at Oklahoma State, Hunter was incredibly productive in
his four years, posting two seasons in which he eclipsed 1,500
rushing yards and 16 TDs (2008 and 2010) while finishing his career
with a 5.9 YPC. Although Hunter doesn’t possess ideal size or
speed, he is a smart, hard-working runner who displays good vision
and instincts. He sets up his blocks well and can make a defender
miss in the hole with above-average quickness. When combined with
his reliable hands and open-field elusiveness, the 2010 All-American
could slide into the RB2 role in San Francisco behind Frank
Gore immediately. Considering the injury history Gore has
(including the hip injury he suffered late last season), new HC
Jim Harbaugh may be inclined to ease up on Gore’s workload a bit
more than previous HC Mike Singletary did. While Anthony
Dixon is no slouch, Harbaugh and the front office obviously
identified Hunter as their kind of back on Day 3 of April’s draft,
so given that Hunter contributes more to the passing game than
Dixon does, he has a leg up on the second-year back should Gore
miss time again this season.
Reasons to dislike Hunter: Despite
his production and big heart, Hunter seems like a bad fit for
an offense that wants to play power football initially. At 5-7
and 200 pounds, Hunter doesn’t move the pile on inside runs and
doesn’t always power through the “easy” tackle, so he is highly
unlikely to serve as a full-time back should Gore miss time. And
while he shows fight in pass protection, defenses will try to
exploit his size if he is asked to block on a regular basis. Because
a fully healthy Gore trumps him in just about every possible way
at this point of his career, Hunter will likely be relegated to
standing on the sidelines along with Dixon when the veteran is
healthy. And if Gore should get hurt, Hunter’s rookie-year upside
is likely as a lead committee back.
Fantasy Assessment: It should be noted that Hunter’s ranking
on this list is based primarily on Gore’s injury history,
meaning Hunter should get 2-3 games to showcase his abilities
with 15+ touches. From a game-to-game consistency standpoint,
Hunter isn’t likely to provide much in terms of fantasy
numbers. But given Gore’s injury history, it’s a good
bet that Hunter will see a bit of action in fantasy lineups at
some point this season, essentially taking over the role Brian
Westbrook served late last season. He’s a mandatory handcuff
for Gore owners and a nice little trade chip for the Gore owners
who let him slide too far late in the draft.
Fearless late-June prediction:
65 rushes for 300 yards and two TDs; 18 receptions for 95 yards
and one TD
18.
Alex Green, RB Green Bay
Reasons to like Green: Despite
the fact that Hawaii has become synonymous with spread formations
and ridiculous passing numbers, Green was insanely productive
in his final season with the Warriors, rushing for 1,199 yards
and 18 scores on just 146 carries (8.2 YPC). Although no team
runs a spread offense full-time in the NFL, the Packers do it
more often than just about any other team. For a RB who measures
in at 6-0 and 225 pounds, Green possesses impressive elusiveness
in the open field and is a solid downhill between-the-tackles
runner – both qualities that play well in Green Bay’s zone-blocking
scheme. Considering Green is the likely replacement for free agent
Brandon
Jackson, Green may win the third-down back role by default,
which will entitle him to regular – albeit limited – playing time
right away when the team pulls Ryan
Grant in passing situations. Grant has been durable for most
of his career prior to last season, but backup James
Starks has not shown a great deal of ability to avoid injury
throughout his young career.
Reasons to dislike Green: While
Green is a physical runner who seeks contact; he almost seeks
it out too much, opting to run over tacklers in the hole as opposed
to making a move. For a back his size, Green goes down too easily
on occasion and runs high, which makes him a prime target for
defenders looking to deliver a big hit or strip the ball. Green
also lacks the patience and vision necessary at this point to
become a feature back – two huge qualities for any RB that runs
behind a zone-blocking line – for the Packers should Grant miss
time again in 2011, meaning he will likely be cast as a passing-down
specialist initially. In regards to his new team, Green faces
an uphill battle at significant time in the Green Bay backfield
should Grant remain upright and Starks take the next step to improve
his durability and become a better all-around back.
Fantasy Assessment: Green isn’t likely to carry too much
value in 2011 as long as Grant stays healthy, but if the veteran
pulls up lame again early in the season, Green has the tools necessary
to lead a committee attack with Starks and produce consistently
in a way Jackson could not. The most likely outcome is that Grant
starts and plays every game for the Packers this season, leaving
Green with a maximum of 70-100 touches. But Grant’s owners
would be wise to handcuff Green and Starks (probably in that order)
to their RB because it is not unthinkable the Packers would be
willing to see what they have in reserve should Grant go down
in the final year of his contract.
Fearless late-June prediction:
50 rushes, 235 yards and three TDs; 28 receptions for 250 yards
and one TD
17.
Titus Young, WR Detroit
Reasons to like Young: If the Lions’
goal was to find someone to stretch the field consistently in
a way Bryant
Johnson never could, they did well to take one of the draft’s
best deep threats in Young. The three-time all-Western Athletic
Conference wideout is exceptionally quick and pulls away from
defensive backs after eating up the defensive back’s cushion.
Young is light on his feet in and out of breaks like DeSean
Jackson although not quite the same overall prospect as the
Eagle standout as some have suggested. For a college receiver,
Young is a solid run-after-catch player, tough for his size (5-11,
174 pounds) and better than many receivers his size at escaping
press coverage. All things considered, Young joins a good situation
in Detroit in that he will almost never be the main focus of a
defense so long as Calvin Johnson is healthy. And if Matthew
Stafford can ever put together an injury-free season, the
third-year signal-caller has a big enough arm to make sure the
Lions get the most out of Young’s deep-ball abilities.
Reasons to dislike Young: Despite
his toughness, Young is nowhere near strong enough right now to
disengage from the NFL’s more physical cornerbacks nor can he
be expected to hold up for a full season if he is asked to go
over the middle on a regular basis. Scouts have labeled Young
a “body-catcher” for his propensity to let the ball come into
his body as opposed to snagging the ball with his hands – a problem
that shows up by the lack of “jump balls” Young wins. While Young
should step right into the WR3 role (moving Nate
Burleson inside in three-WR sets), the Boise State product
figures to be highly inconsistent on a game-to-game basis since
Detroit has a plethora of offensive weapons that should be higher
on the priority list in the passing game (Calvin
Johnson, Burleson, TE Brandon
Pettigrew and possibly RB Jahvid
Best). Young also was suspended for the final nine games of
the 2008 season for violating unspecified team rules. While he
has reportedly learned from his mistakes and matured, he still
has a reputation as an egotistical player who tends to resist
coaching.
Fantasy Assessment: In an offense that is just overflowing with
skill-position talent, it’s hard not to like Young at the
end of fantasy drafts as a receiver who can take advantage of
a matchup, much like Pittsburgh’s third receivers have done
lately (Nate Washington, Mike Wallace and Emmanuel Sanders). The
fact that GM Martin Mayhew sees Young as a “stick of dynamite”
that he expects to “step in immediately” means that
the rookie should initially be considered as solid roster depth
in deeper fantasy leagues and a watch-list candidate in shallow
leagues. As with most rookie receivers, he will probably deliver
two or three duds for every big game he produces in 2011, but
as long as Stafford remains upright, Young is a solid bet to give
his owners at least one big play a game.
Fearless late-June prediction:
36 receptions for 500 yards and three TDs
16.
Jonathan Baldwin, WR Kansas City
Reasons to like Baldwin: If this
6-4, 230-pound behemoth wasn’t the best combination of size and
speed at receiver in April’s draft, he wasn’t too far behind.
Given what HC Todd Haley will likely ask out of him in Year 1
and his penchant for using his body well to make incredible catches
downfield, those qualities alone may be enough to get Baldwin
into the starting lineup early in his rookie season. In terms
of learning his craft, the former Pitt Panther couldn’t ask for
a much better situation as Haley is starting to build quite a
resume when it comes to getting the most out of his receivers.
As far as the offense he is joining, Kansas City may be happy
just to see him emerge as a deep threat in 2011. With Dwayne
Bowe on the other side, Tony
Moeaki over the middle and one of the best running games in
the NFL, Baldwin is almost guaranteed to see single coverage on
every play his rookie season.
Reasons to dislike Baldwin: First
and foremost, receivers with Baldwin’s size and speed typically
don’t last until the last part of the first round unless there
is a legitimate injury or character concern. In Baldwin’s case,
it is the latter. While he was found not guilty on a number of
misdemeanor charges for an arrest in 2009, Baldwin committed a
pretty big no-no (at least in the eyes of scouts and coaches)
when he ripped his college quarterback and coaches around the
same time he declared for the draft. On the field, he is just
the latest in a line of mega-talented college receivers who can
make the difficult catch look easy and the easy catch look difficult.
Furthermore, his effort has been questioned on multiple occasions
and his route-running is far from refined. Combine all that with
the fact that the Chiefs’ offense is run-based with a relatively
inaccurate QB leading the passing game. And while Kansas City
wants to open up the offense a bit more this season, the combined
production of all Chiefs’ receivers outside of Bowe was pathetic
last season: 67 catches, 693 yards and three receiving touchdowns.
Fantasy Assessment: It seems the “knucklehead factor”
is more prevalent at receiver than any other position nowadays.
Sometimes as fantasy owners and/or forecasters, trying to decide
whether a player is just being an immature brat or a is truly
a bad seed is one of the toughest calls to make – a decision
that can come at a fairly heavy price in fantasy draft pick compensation
when the player is as talented as Baldwin is. Haley has already
gone on record as saying he expects immediate contribution from
his first-rounder, but conventional wisdom suggests we should
expect the same up-and-down production from Baldwin that most
rookie receivers provide. Unless Kansas City dramatically shifts
its offensive philosophy, it will remain a running team. Assuming
Baldwin cracks the opening day lineup, he will likely accentuate
Jamaal Charles’ game-breaking ability more than light up
fantasy box scores. Expect 3-4 big games at most with a lot of
inconsistency in between.
Fearless late-June prediction:
38 receptions for 515 yards and four TDs
15.
Leonard Hankerson, WR Washington
Reasons to like Hankerson: Considering
Hankerson hails from the same school that helped usher the careers
of Michael Irvin, Santana Moss, Reggie
Wayne and Andre
Johnson, it is quite impressive that he owns a number of single-season
records at the University of Miami (FL), including receptions
(72), receiving yards (1,156) and receiving TDs (13). He did this
despite average play at best from the quarterback position. Despite
being somewhat average in terms of size (6-2, 209), Hankerson
plays very big for his size by impressively shielding off defenders
as a receiver and running through tackles. Unlike some of his
fellow 2011 draft classmates, Hankerson is a strong locker-room
presence and is a pretty capable blocker, which should endear
him quickly to the Redskins’ coaching staff. In Washington, Hankerson
doesn’t exactly face the stiffest of competition at his position
and should start the season out no lower than a WR3 – assuming
free agent Santana
Moss returns. If Moss departs, the third-rounder will only
need to beat out the disappointing Malcolm
Kelly for a starting job opposite Anthony
Armstrong. If Moss returns, Hankerson could very well win
a training-camp battle with Armstrong.
Reasons to dislike Hankerson: Although
he shocked most scouts and GMs at the Combine with one of the
fastest 40 times at his position, Hankerson doesn’t profile as
a NFL deep threat and will likely make his living in the pros
as a possession receiver. While that isn’t necessarily a bad thing,
he isn’t the quickest player either, which means he will need
to be very sound in his route-running and technique against cornerbacks
who attempt to play bump-and-run against him. Although HC Mike
Shanahan has typically been able to get the most of his receivers’
abilities over the years, the QB situation – as it stands now
before free agency – is one of the most dire in the NFL with only
John
Beck and Rex
Grossman on the roster (if Donovan McNabb moves on as most
expect).
Fantasy Assessment: Before we can really put a rock-solid ranking
on Hankerson’s potential contributions as a rookie, there
are several questions that need to be answered: who will be his
QB and will Moss return? Assuming the Redskins land Matt Hasselbeck
or Marc Bulger and keep Moss (which is my best guess at this point),
Hankerson has a shot at putting together a few fantasy-relevant
performances in 2011. If the team doesn’t sign/trade for
a starter-worthy free-agent QB and/or lets Moss walk, then all
bets are off with a QB-WR depth chart that rivals the 2010 Cleveland
Browns – in other words, a fantasy wasteland.
Fearless late-June prediction:
40 receptions for 525 yards and four TDs
14.
Cam Newton, QB Carolina
Reasons to like Newton: The 2010
Heisman Award winner may be one of the greatest athletic talents
to ever come out of the draft. In fact, his physical talent is
so undeniable that offensive coordinators won’t hesitate to alter
their offensive approach dramatically to adapt to his run-pass
abilities. Despite a number of off-field incidents and/or comments
that has landed Newton in hot water, all the No.1 overall pick
has done in the past two seasons is collect two national championships
(the first one at his junior college and the second with Auburn
this past year), so he is a winner. Newton unfortunately drew
JaMarcus
Russell comparisons throughout the draft process, but Panthers
fans can be assured that while both are big QBs with huge arms,
Newton’s mental makeup and desire to work is not in question –
one only needs. In terms of the team he is joining, Newton will
have the pleasure of joining a stable of RBs – even if DeAngelo
Williams leaves via free agency – led by Jonathan
Stewart that will go a long way in helping the rookie feel
as comfortable as possible. As far as his receivers are concerned,
Jeremy
Shockey – despite his lack of durability and declining ability
– is the best TE Carolina has employed in years.
Reasons to dislike Newton: Newton’s
biggest challenge is the mental part of the game – even more so
than the average QB coming into the league. And when I say that,
it’s not that he lacks football IQ, it is simply that he hasn’t
been asked to prove it on a regular basis with his coaches asking
him to make a play with his feet if his first read wasn’t open.
He’ll also be asked to work under center regularly after working
out of shotgun – a transition that requires learning to read the
defense at the line scrimmage and during his dropback (not to
mention the footwork that goes along with it) as opposed to the
rock-and-fire motion most spread QBs are accustomed to in college
football. And let’s just say we can assume that he can make all
the necessary improvements (which is almost impossible to expect),
there is the matter of the talent he will be throwing to – a group
of receivers that may be the worst in the league, especially if
Steve
Smith is traded like many expect him to be. David
Gettis and Brandon
LaFell each showed flashes last season, but Shockey is the
only Panther that has earned any kind of respect in the NFL. What
this means –if Smith is traded – is that Newton and Stewart will
be seeing an awful lot of eight-in-the-box on running downs and
complex coverages on passing downs.
Fantasy Assessment: Even with a poor group of receivers to throw
to in 2011, Newton’s athleticism alone will enable him to
be fantasy relevant at some point this season since any camp competition
with Jimmy Clausen figures to be one-sided in favor of the more
highly-paid player. It would be unfair to expect Newton to emulate
the late-season run of another highly-touted college spread QB
he has been compared to (Tim Tebow), but it is possible that he
may post enough rushing yards to finish just outside the top 20
fantasy QBs if he ends up starting Week 1. Any owner investing
in him should be prepared for a bumpy and inconsistent ride, however.
Fearless late-June prediction (14 games):
205-of-365 for 2310 yards, 10 TD and 15 INT; 115 rushes for 615
yards and five rushing TDs
13.
Lance Kendricks, TE St. Louis
Reasons to like Kendricks: Although
the notion of big-play TEs isn’t a new concept, the focus of acquiring
one has become more pronounced in recent years with the dearth
of all-around players at the position. In Kendricks, St. Louis
likely landed the draft’s most athletic TE and the player most
likely to contribute right away at his position in large part
due to the wide-open offense he will be joining. Much like other
athletic TEs who have been drafted of late, Kendricks is a former
wide receiver who has kept much of his downfield speed, can find
a hole in zone coverage and possesses the ability to make the
great catch – even if his concentration wanes on the “easy” catch
from time to time.
Reasons to dislike Kendricks: While
he is a willing blocker, Kendricks isn’t likely to remain in the
lineup consistently (at least not right away) when the Rams decide
to go with two TEs and pound the defense with Steven
Jackson. Therefore, short-yardage and goal-line opportunities
may not be in his immediate future. With that said, he isn’t a
liability as a blocker, so the likelihood is good that he will
emerge as an every-down, every-situation TE early in his career.
Fantasy Assessment: Of all the places I expected Kendricks to
land in April, St. Louis would have likely ranked #32 given how
new OC Josh McDaniels has used TEs in New England and Denver.
However, from the day he was drafted, there has been strong sentiment
the 6-3 and 243-pound big-play threat will be used in much the
same way Aaron Hernandez was with the Patriots last season while
Michael Hoomanwanui assumes the Rob Gronkowski role. With the
plethora of possession receiver types in St. Louis (as well as
injury-prone players such as Donnie Avery and Laurent Robinson),
Kendricks has a very good shot at emerging as the Rams’
best downfield threat as a rookie so long as they don’t
ask him to take on too many roles. But while the Hernandez comparisons
are apt in terms of role and ability, don’t expect the same
kind of per-game production for Kendricks this season as Hernandez
provided in 2010.
Fearless late-June prediction:
42 receptions for 540 yards and four TDs
12.
DeMarco Murray, RB Dallas
Reason to like Murray: Versatility.
Reasons to like Murray: In
terms of athletic and receiving ability, Murray is right at the
top of this rookie RB class. Much like one of his new teammates
(Felix
Jones), Murray is at his best on outside runs and in space
where he gets to put his speed and quickness on display. Along
with exceptional hands (71 catches in 2010, 157 for his career),
the University of Oklahoma’s record-holder in TDs, points, all-purpose
yards and receiving yards by a RB is more than adequate in blitz
pickup, which means he could be fast-tracked into a third-down
role for the Cowboys. Along with his explosiveness, his best trait
may be his versatility, which may allow him to be a jack of all
trades as his career progresses. Murray also scored high marks
from scouts and general managers alike with his special-teams
abilities, dedication and work ethic. At 6-0 and 214 pounds, Murray
has the frame to add about 10 more pounds of muscle over the next
year or two, which may go a long way in improving his confidence
as an inside runner and allow him to take a bit more punishment
at the same time. In Dallas, the two-time first-team All-Big 12
selection enters a talented backfield, but one in which he could
make some noise immediately should everything fall just right
for him. In an offense that features such top-notch talent in
the passing game (Miles
Austin, Dez
Bryant and Jason
Witten to name a few), Murray may have more opportunity than
the average rookie to break some huge plays when his number is
called on draws or screens.
Reasons to dislike Murray: Despite
playing 50 games in his college career, Murray’s durability is
one of the biggest worries the Cowboys will have going forward.
(He played through a turf toe in 2006, missed three games after
dislocating his right knee cap in 2007, missed the final two games
of 2008 after rupturing a hamstring, missed two more games with
a sprained ankle in 2009 and suffered bruised ribs in 2010.) While
he is elusive in the open field and an able north-south, one-cut
runner, his WR-like build and upright running style makes him
a difficult projection as an every-down running back in the NFL,
especially in light of his injury history. When combined with
subpar vision inside and the absence of pile-moving power, it
may explain why HC Jason Garrett has already stated his intention
to move Murray all over the field with talk about putting him
in the slot and even as an outside receiver in certain packages.
As far as his immediate future with the Cowboys, Murray will be
hard-pressed to threaten Jones for the starting job right away
and he may not even win the RB2 job if Tashard
Choice is given a fair shot to claim that role. (And this
is even assuming Marion
Barber does not return.)
Fantasy Assessment: Murray is an interesting wild-card for fantasy
owners in 2011. Considering the concerns most talent evaluators
have regarding his durability, it seems far-fetched that he has
a realistic shot at finishing the season atop the depth chart
(as one columnist from the Dallas Morning News suggested in early
June). Still, if Barber is allowed to leave and the coaching staff
insists on keeping Choice buried on the depth chart, then the
rookie has a fair shot of some relevancy in fantasy leagues early
on. Murray is likely at least one year away from even considering
starting RB duties since the team will almost certainly ask him
to add muscle, but owners – especially those in PPR leagues
– need to keep an eye on any explosive pass-catching back
who may touch the ball 8-10 times per game in what figures to
be a high-scoring offense.
Fearless late-June prediction:
110 rushes for 520 yards and four TDs; 28 receptions for 250 yards
and two TDs
11.
Alex Henery, K Philadelphia
Reasons to like Henery: Henery
belongs on the short list of the greatest kickers in college football
history. Not only did he finish as the school’s all-time leading
scorer, but Henery also became the most accurate kicker in NCAA
history, connecting on 89.5% (68-of-76 FG) of his attempts throughout
his four-year career. He was so ridiculously good that he missed
just one kick each between 30-39 yards and 40-49 yards in his
college career. All his other misses came from 50+ yards (5-of-11)
and two of those were blocked. While kicking in college is admittedly
not kicking in the NFL, don’t expect pressure or cold weather
of Philadelphia to faze Henery after playing at Nebraska.
Reasons to dislike Henery: There
are very few reasons not to like Henery, outside of the fact that
most people have a natural inclination to dismiss kickers in general.
Some draftniks suggest that he loses accuracy as he moves further
back, but that’s true of all kickers. (Seriously, Henery’s one
miss in 2010 came on a blocked attempt from 51 yards out.) The
one potential downfall Henery may have this season is that Philadelphia
has enough dynamic offensive talent that it may not require a
high number of field goal attempts.
Fantasy Assessment: While a selection of a kicker this high is
bound to draw the ire of a few skeptics, the fact of the matter
is it isn’t often when an accurate, clutch kicker with the
leg of a Mason Crosby joins a dynamic offense. For many years,
David Akers was a favorite of fantasy owners in large part because
Philadelphia’s offense has traditionally been good at getting
into scoring position but not finishing drives. Reid’s pass-heavy
offensive attack isn’t going to change anytime soon, so
when one considers that Akers has attempted at least 37 field
goals AND 40 extra points in three straight seasons, the chances
that Henery does the same are pretty high. Considering his big
leg, it’s not out of the question he gets two or three more
attempts from 55-60 yards that Philly would not have asked from
Akers. Henery should be a top 5-6 kicker selection and should
actually be valued more by fantasy owners this season than if
the Eagles had decided to hold on to Akers.
Fearless late-June prediction:
34-of-40 FG; 41-of-41 XP
Suggestions, comments, musings about the article or fantasy football
in general? E-mail me.
Doug Orth has written for FF Today since 2006, appeared
in USA Today’s Fantasy Football Preview magazine in each
of the last two seasons and served as a weekly fantasy football
analyst for 106.7 The Fan in Washington, D.C. this past season.
He is also a member of the Fantasy Sports Writers Association.
You can also follow him
on Twitter.
|