Early Observations - NFC
7/13/10
ARI | ATL | CAR
| CHI | DAL | DET
| GB | MIN | NO
| NYG | PHI | STL
| SF | SEA | TB
| WAS | AFC
All of us know there is a lot of "fluff" that gets thrown
around during the NFL offseason so beat writers will have something
to write and editors will have something with which to fill space.
With the proliferation of studio shows like Total Access
and NFL Live running year-round, it gets harder to separate
what we know from what we don't know because there is a good chance
we've heard the same fluff repeated multiple times by different
"experts".
However, if there is a small amount of truth to every lie - as
the saying goes - there are some useful morsels of information
that fantasy owners can take from the very people who "lie"
to us in the media. Some of them get paid handsomely to analyze
trends, stats, etc for us, but with many of these "experts",
it is clear they are done for the day when their shift (or show)
is over. And unfortunately, many of these folks take the easy
way out and bow to the power of the popular opinion in the end
anyway.
I want to let it be known my "Early Observations" contributions
over the past two weeks are on the topics that I believe fantasy
owners would want information on, in other words, actual news
from the reporters covering the team since the offseason began.
(The fact that it comes with my opinions attached is just a bonus.)
Most fantasy football veterans are aware that about 75% of what
comes out of a beat writer's mouth - or computer, as it were -
is either hyperbole, opinion or both and it is usually questionable
information at that. Thus, think of me - for this week anyway
- as a filter, a conduit that can help each of you sort the fact
from the fiction and allow you to get another fantasy owner's
take on the information that has been presented to us over the
last few months.
With this being a fantasy column and many of you either well
into your draft preparation or about ready to start, it seemed
like a good idea to stay on the offensive side of the ball for
now – we’ll tackle the defense next week. Without
further delay, let's dive into the NFC.
Arizona
One of the bigger offseason storylines in the NFL this season
is Matt Leinart and whether or not he can make the most of his
second chance to make a first impression. Offseason reports have
varied widely on his competition with ex-Browns QB Derek Anderson,
with some outlets suggesting in early May that Leinart looked
to be “in command” while another outlet reported in
late May that “neither signal-caller was terribly impressive
in mini-camp” back to Leinart had taken a “step forward”
by early June. Considering the reports were less than a month
apart, well, now you can see why I am not a big fan of blindly
following some writer or a certain website just because they are
an industry giant.
For his part, HC Ken Whisenhunt has been squarely in the corner
of Leinart from the start, supporting his beleaguered QB in the
media time and time again. QBs coach Chris Miller – one
of the up-and-coming position coaches in the league – has
adjusted the mechanics of both Leinart and Anderson, getting each
QB to shorten their stride in an effort to improve their accuracy.
No fantasy owner should expect the fantasy production Kurt Warner
was able to manage in his last few years in Arizona from Leinart
or Anderson anytime soon simply because this offense will be more
balanced than any Whisenhunt-coached Cards’ team has been
up to this point. However, anyone who saw Anderson in Cleveland
lately knows that Leinart will have to be borderline terrible
to lose his starting job. And with the receiving crew Arizona
has, it’s not unthinkable that Leinart could be a strong
matchup-QB for fantasy purposes this season.
It’s very easy to take for granted that Steve Breaston
is the natural selection to slide into Anquan Boldin’s old
flanker slot, but that could end up being a very bad assumption.
Early Doucet has been diligent in his offseason workouts –
dropping seven pounds in order to play at 205 – and is impressing
every Cardinals’ player or coach that is asked about him.
Doucet may be setting the stage for the “third-year WR breakout”
in part because he seems to be maturing in terms of his
renewed focus and enjoyed the spoils that came along with
a two-game playoff run (14 catches for 145 yards and two touchdowns
after a disappointing 17-catch, 214-yard, 1-TD regular season).
Perhaps the most exciting part of the new Doucet is what Larry
Fitzgerald says about him in regards to his toughness, if not
other parts of his game: “he reminds me of Q (Boldin’s
nickname)”. Fitzgerald is going to be the WR1 in town for
the foreseeable future, but Doucet was the player Arizona had
its eye on to one day replace Boldin. It may not happen in 2010,
but it appears right now there is every bit the chance the Cardinals
decide Breaston is the WR2 as he is the WR3. Fantasy owners would
be wise to reduce the near six-round gap in the ADP (9.1 to 14.11)
between Breaston and Doucet now because this may be a closer call
than many believe.
Roddy White: Having a fantabulous offseason.
Atlanta
Last year, I had two major reasons to dislike Michael Turner:
1) I did not like his 2009 schedule and the fact that he beat
up on all the weak teams to get the majority of his numbers the
previous year and 2) his 2008 workload suggested that a breakdown
may be coming. The one very few of us saw coming – if any
of us saw it – was his hush-hush weight
gain that pushed him over 250 pounds last summer. While the
“Curse of 370”
is debatable to a certain degree – in football, players
(especially running backs) are almost always putting themselves
in position to be injured; some just beat the odds more often
than others – the fact that Turner was carrying a few more
pounds than his usual 244 could explain the lack of explosion
“The Burner” showed in 2009. Along with the fact that
HC Mike Smith feels that his RB is in “the best shape of
his Falcons’ career”, the offensive line remains intact
from a season ago – the same one that allowed Turner and
Jason Snelling to rush for 4.9 and 4.3 YPC respectively last season
vs. a fairly stout schedule. One-trick RBs (backs who only contribute
in one area such as rushing, receiving or at the goal line) in
fantasy are always a dicey proposition, but at the rate he scores,
it is hard to say his scoring prowess doesn’t make up for
his inability to contribute in the passing game.
If any one player on the Falcons’ roster wanted to rest
on their laurels, it would be Roddy White. Granted, he wasn’t
the most consistent fantasy force last season, but his year-end
fantasy point per game totals over the past three seasons have
been remarkably consistent (14.7, 16.7, 16.7). So, it makes what
I’m about to say even more impressive: according to OC Mike
Mularkey, White has enjoyed “maybe one of the best offseasons
as a WR since I (Mularkey) have been in the league”. (Bear
in mind that Mularkey has worked with the likes of Hines Ward
and Eric Moulds, among others.) With many of the same faces in
the same offense going into their third season together, the stage
is being set for White to possibly crack the 90-catch barrier
for the first time in his career. Last season proved Tony Gonzalez
was a player that would benefit White but not undermine his overall
fantasy value. As much as it limits the potential upside of the
offense that Atlanta cannot upgrade from Michael Jenkins opposite
White, the six-year veteran has been carrying the Falcons’
passing game for years, so at 28 years of age and Gonzalez helping
to take attention away from him, White appears poised for another
top-10 fantasy season at his position.
Carolina
It’s a bad deal when the one player that a team is expecting
to carry its passing game goes down playing flag football, but
such is the case for Steve Smith and the Panthers. Unfortunately,
it’s the same left arm he broke in Week 16 last season.
So, whether Carolina wanted to or not, it must trot out what looks
to be an uninspiring lot of supporting cast members to replace
the 31-year-old veteran, who believes he will be back in time
for the regular season opener after he was given a 10-week recovery
window by doctors. In his stead, Kenneth Moore will man his spot
while disappointing Dwayne Jarrett will face off against the talented
rookie Brandon LaFell for the right to start opposite Smith. Another
rookie, Armanti Edwards, will be given every chance to man the
slot in three-wide packages. About the only thing Jarrett has
going for him is that HC John Fox is well-known for his tendency
to play the veteran over a rookie. Still, expect LaFell to be
fantasy-relevant at some point this season and take command of
the position. As for Smith, it’s tough to hype a player
missing so much preseason action, but his injury presents an excellent
buy-low opportunity. Sure, the on-field bonding time with new
QB Matt Moore would have been nice, but unfamiliarity did not
seem to matter a great deal down the stretch in 2009. Beginning
with Moore’s first start in Week 13, Smith averaged 18.7
FPPG in PPR and 14 in non-PPR in their four games together, numbers
in stark contrast with the 12.1 FPPG (PPR) and 7.6 (non-PPR) with
Jake Delhomme as the starter.
Speaking of Moore, I believe he has a better grasp on the starting
job than most people think. Rookie Jimmy Clausen has a definite
leg up on most rookie QBs as he joins an offensive system just
like the one he left at Notre Dame, but Moore is 6-2 overall as
a starter in Carolina and is coming off a season-ending five-game
stretch in 2009 in which he
was the league’s second-highest rated passer. Working
further against the rookie is Fox’s aforementioned penchant
for playing veterans over rookies (sometimes to a fault, as was
the case with Delhomme last season). Still, if Smith’s interview
on NFL Network’s Total Access program last month can be
taken at face value, he believes the Panthers now have two franchise
QBs. While I won’t go that far – and Carolina will
be a running so long as Fox is the coach – I think there’s
a good chance Moore starts all year long barring injury and makes
himself a player that could be started in a pinch in fantasy.
Chicago
Things were going to be interesting in “the Windy City”
from the moment OC Mike Martz was hired – we just didn’t
know it was going to be THIS interesting. In one corner, we have
the “firmly entrenched” split end Johnny Knox (the
Torry Holt spot in Martz’s offense). In another corner,
there is the receiver Jay Cutler hasn’t stopped praising
since the end of last year, Devin Aromashodu. In yet another quarter,
we have the people’s champ in Devin Hester, who is slated
to play flanker (the Isaac Bruce role of the offense) and the
one receiver that actually looked like a WR1 for a prolonged stretch
last season. And let’s not forget Earl Bennett, one of last
season’s favorite sleeper candidates. Suffice it to say
that a lot of reports have been coming out of Bears’ camp
this offseason, so much so that it is hard to follow who is going
to be the focus of the offense this week or “the guy we
need to get the ball to more” next week. Regardless of whether
or not Aromashodu is actually named a starter, it should be noted
that he is undoubtedly Cutler’s favorite WR (at least in
the media anyway). And we all know if a QB trusts one receiver
more than any of the others, that receiver is likely the one to
be the most consistent in fantasy. Furthermore, we don’t
have to go back too far to remember that talented slot WRs in
Martz’s scheme tend to do pretty well (Az Hakim, Mike Furrey,
Shaun McDonald). Most likely, all three players will be very usable
in fantasy for most of the season, if not all of it. Just don’t
be too surprised if you see Aromashodu at the top of the fantasy
leaderboard when it comes to Bears’ WRs in 2010.
While the addition of Chester Taylor was not a puzzling one,
the decision to view him as a “second starter” is
a bit more of a head-scratcher. It was clear early on that Forte
was not right last season (weight gain along with a torn hamstring
and an early-season MCL sprain) and his offensive line was atrocious
last season, especially when it came to run-blocking. On the other
hand, one certainly has to question what Taylor has left as he
nears his age-31 season coming off a season in which he averaged
a paltry 3.6 YPC behind a much better run-blocking line in Minnesota.
As such, I eventually expect Chicago to realize Taylor will serve
the team best in a complementary role, allowing Forte to recapture
a bit of the appeal he lost in 2009. Taylor’s presence will
affect Forte’s PPR value to be sure, but as time goes on,
I imagine the incumbent will receive more and more of the work
on the ground. As we know, that doesn’t mean a lot in a
Martz offense, but for as much as he was viewed as a disappointment
last season, Forte only dropped to 12th in PPR and 18th in PPR,
which still makes him a quality RB2 in fantasy. If all he does
this year is become slightly more efficient with his touches –
a distinct possibility if he is healthy – he’s a fair
bet to hold onto fantasy RB2 value all season long.
Dallas
There’s no debate on whether or not Roy Williams has been
a disappointment as a Cowboy – he has been. But are fantasy
owners being too quick to dismiss him this season? Possibly. And
that very possibility makes him potentially undervalued this year
and also means rookie Dez Bryant is probably greatly overvalued.
No one is going to question Bryant’s potential or raw physical
ability, but to completely dismiss Williams is foolish in my mind.
While skill is obvious – most of the time – to coaches,
if there is one thing that is stronger than that, it is that billionaire
owners tend to refuse the notion they are wrong. Because Jerry
Jones invested so much into Williams, he is going to get every
chance to “earn” his contract and return the draft-pick
investment Jones made into him. Therefore, this has all the makings
of a 50-50 or 60-40 time-share, neither of which is good for either
player’s fantasy standing. And let’s be real –
however Williams vs. Bryant shakes out, the winner will be only
the #3 option in the passing game.
Barber vs. Jones: Two talented backs muddies
the fantasy waters.
Moving from WRs to RBs, another hot topic in Texas is how the
backfield work will be assigned to Marion Barber and Felix Jones.
Both players have received the Jones’ seal of approval as
a starter, so this may actually be one position in Dallas that
gets settled on the practice field and not in the front office.
Interestingly enough, both players are attempting to look more
like the other, with Jones adding muscle to his upper half (now
up to 225 pounds) while Barber is dropping weight (reportedly
down to 212). Regardless of all the enthusiasm surrounding the
big-play ability of Jones, it should be remembered that he has
been much too injury-prone in his short NFL career to be counted
on for a huge workload on a weekly basis. I expect this situation
to play out in much the same way as it was going at the end of
last season, perhaps with the main difference being that Jones
may start this time around. Otherwise, I expect Jones’ workload
ceiling to be roughly 16 carries with Barber still being the back
of choice at the goal line and in the fourth quarter. In the best-case
scenario, this backfield ends up enjoying the same level of production
that Tennessee enjoyed with Chris Johnson and LenDale White in
2008. I see both players maintaining RB2 value throughout the
season, with both players likely to perform right around their
current ADP (5.03 for Jones; 6.11 for Barber).
Detroit
It’s been said countless times that the NFL is a copycat
league. In much the same respect, when coaches and GMs see a player
they REALLY like on the playing field, they wonder what it would
be like if their team had one of those players. In the case of
rookie Jahvid Best, HC Jim Schwartz isn’t all that insane
for wanting to model his new prized RB after the example of Chris
Johnson, who Schwartz coached against every day in practice in
2008 as the Titans’ defensive coordinator. I have been on
Best’s bandwagon for some time, but with the weapons Detroit
is starting to assemble in the passing game, Best is set to enjoy
a lot of running room. Defenses simply will not be able to load
the box with Calvin Johnson, Nate Burleson, Tony Scheffler and
Brandon Pettigrew all distracting opposing defenses. The rookie’s
teammates – offensive and defensive – are already
admiring
the blur that Best creates when he puts his speed on display
in practice. If Vincent Jackson and Marcus McNeill continue their
holdout in Seattle, then it is Best who become the rookie that
most fantasy owners should target in the early rounds, not Ryan
Mathews. Much like Mathews, the former Cal product has a questionable
run-blocking line to operate behind. But speed can be intoxicating
for coaches and fans alike, so expect Detroit to get drunk on
Best by the time the season starts. Assuming he can hold up for
an entire NFL season, I would be stunned if Best doesn’t
outperform his current mid-fifth round ADP by at least a round,
if not two or three.
When Detroit acquired Scheffler via trade for a fifth-round pick
in April, it made sense that he would be considered merely insurance
in case Pettigrew’s recovery from ACL surgery did not go
as planned. However, as we stand here in July, Detroit expects
Pettigrew back on the field to start the season and has
big plans for Scheffler in the base offense, either as another
blocker in the run game (even though that is not his forte) or
as a Dallas Clark-like threat in the passing game. Scheffler has
the ability to contribute in the latter fashion, but the Lions
will be hard-pressed to use Scheffler to that degree if they hope
to center their offense around Johnson and Best while keeping
Burleson and Pettigrew involved. Scheffler could flirt with TE1
status in fantasy this season and should finish in or around that
neighborhood, but he isn’t even on the radar ADP-wise right
now, so feel free to snag him as a “high-upside” pick
in the late rounds.
Green Bay
One of the more under-the-radar stories this offseason was the
scopes Donald Driver had done to both knees in January. Fantasy
owners have been calling for Driver’s decline for what seems
like years, but this time we may have enough reason to send him
spiraling down our cheatsheets. For what it is worth, the coaching
staff decided to rest him during OTAs, presumably because there
was little reason to put the 35-year-old through the paces of
an OTA when he obviously knows the offense and is trying to remain
as healthy as possible. However, it is interesting to note that
Driver’s production fell drastically in the second half
of last season for several reasons (his knees, Jermichael Finley’s
return from injury, better protection for Aaron Rodgers allowed
him to take shots down the field with Greg Jennings among them),
but have we seen the last of his productive days? On a normal
run-of-the-mill offense, the answer would likely be “no”,
but Green Bay has been keeping James Jones and Jordy Nelson under
wraps for a while now. Nelson, for one, appears
to be sensing his opportunity. Don’t overreact too much
yet to Driver’s situation quite yet, but early drafters
may be forced to make a decision on him, in which case, I’d
advise them to avoid Driver. For the rest of us, definitely keep
an eye on Driver’s ability to plant his foot and make cuts
during the preseason, because that should tell us everything we
need to know about his health at that point. Thus, it would be
wise to spend a late-round pick on Jones or Nelson in deep leagues.
With boxing becoming a more popular method of offseason training
for football players, it’s not often newsworthy when a player
does it anymore. That is, unless that player is Jermichael Finley
– the same player who was dogged by questions about his
work ethic and immaturity during his first two seasons in the
league. In addition to working out with pro boxer Brian Vera early
in the offseason, Finley accepted an invitation to Larry Fitzgerald’s
now-famous offseason camp – which stresses conditioning,
attention to detail and time-management skills. It’s also
the same camp that Sidney Rice participated in last summer and
later praised in helping him achieve his breakout 2009. What’s
more about Finley’s “attitude adjustment” is
that he is doing all this with tendinitis in his knee, the same
one that sidelined during the middle of the 2009 season. It was
going to take something special for an outsider to sneak into
the elite fantasy TEs that includes the likes Antonio Gates, Jason
Witten, Tony Gonzalez, Vernon Davis, Brent Celek and Dallas Clark,
but given Finley’s finish to last season, his commitment
to excellence this offseason and his promotion to the starting
lineup, it is hard to not like him as a dark-horse pick for the
top TE in fantasy for the 2010 season.
Minnesota
Most of the time, Adrian Peterson is a RB to watch for all the
right reasons. Unfortunately, in 2009, he did his best to keep
both teams in the game at times. The unfortunate part of Peterson’s
year is that his fumbles overshadowed the fact he obliterated
his previous career highs in TDs (18) and receptions (43). And
to be fair, Peterson actually fumbled more in 2008 (nine, lost
four) than he did last season (seven, six), but as Minnesota evolves
into a complete offense, defenses are realizing the best way to
stop the Vikings is to get into the head of Peterson. To that
end, Peterson has started
practicing with a sand-filled, 14-pound ball in hopes that
the repetition of keeping the “heavy ball” tucked
in will rub off on him when he takes the field. As much as the
fumbling issue may continue to be a problem, the points lost by
fantasy owners for those fumbles aren’t worth losing the
piece of mind that comes with putting AP in your lineup each and
every week. I’m still deciding whether he is my #1 or #2
overall RB in fantasy, but Peterson’s 2009 stat line may
just be a tease for what he does in 2010. I expect roughly 1600
yards rushing this season while his TDs and receptions remain
about the same as they were last season.
While AP owners are probably happy that Chester Taylor will no
longer be around to steal his receptions, I would be quick to
remind those same people that Minnesota has no shortage of players
who can more than make up for the 700+ yards that Taylor accounted
for in 2009. First and foremost, Percy Harvin will probably receive
a sizable chunk of the 44 catches that Taylor leaves behind, with
perhaps some limited work as a rusher mixed in. What Harvin doesn’t
take, Sidney Rice and Visanthe Shiancoe probably will. On the
rushing end of it, rookie Toby Gerhart figures to absorb the 100
or so carries that Taylor was usually good for behind AP. In short,
Peterson isn’t going to take another 20-catch leap from
43 to 60+ catches one year after he went from 21 to 43 receptions.
New Orleans
Along with Donald Driver’s knee scopes, perhaps the quietest
surgery that occurred in the offseason to a potential starting
WR in fantasy was performed on the toe of Robert Meachem. While
HC Sean Payton is optimistic about his receiver’s ability
to return by training camp, Meachem
himself doesn’t sound so sure. Any serious fantasy football
owner knows that every toe surgery sounds minor but, in reality,
can linger and affect the way an athlete cuts and runs. With Drew
Brees’ penchant to throw the ball to the open WR rather
than focus on 1-2 players on a given route, it is vital that Meachem
is ready to go without restriction early in training camp. It’s
already enough that the Saints have introduced a new WR to the
fantasy scene since the arrival of Brees and Payton (Meachem,
2009; Lance Moore, 2008; David Patten, 2007 and Marques Colston,
2006), so keep that in mind when deciding on the likelihood that
Meachem carries over his spectacular second half into the 2010
season.
When the Saints invested a third-round pick on University of Miami
(FL) TE Jimmy Graham in April’s draft, most saw the selection
as a pet project for Payton. After all, Graham played only one
year of football for the Hurricanes (catching 17 balls for 213
yards and five TDs) after playing four years on the basketball
team, where he was an accomplished shot blocker. But given the
NFL’s quest for the next Antonio Gates, New Orleans decided
to invest in the potential of the 6-8, 260-pound athlete. Apparently,
all
is going well, because by the end of the OTA sessions, the
talk was when, not if, Graham would overtake Jeremy Shockey.
Obviously, Graham is not for the faint of heart or re-draft owners,
but keeper and dynasty leaguers should prepare for the possibility
that Graham supplants Shockey in 2011.
New York Giants
One season after Steve Smith became the first WR in Giants’
history to catch 100 passes in a single season, it may be time
to talk about him playing second-fiddle. Now before people
get carried away (and by the looks of some of the early drafts
I’ve seen, they are), Hakeem Nicks has two hurdles to overcome
if he hopes to overtake Smith: 1) the “other” Steve
Smith is Eli Manning’s most trusted target and 2) Nicks
is still raw as it relates to being a NFL receiver. Also consider
the Giants will do everything in their power to run the ball like
they did in from 2004-2008. With Smith being Manning’s No.
1 target and a revitalized running game, Nicks’ stat line
could actually improve quite a bit and he’d still be considered
a disappointment for those owners investing a fourth-round fantasy
pick on him. There’s no denying he will probably overtake
Smith at some point, but I’m not sure this is the year.
The earliest I’d consider the second-year WR is at his current
6.01 ADP, but not before the likes of players such as Hines Ward
or Brent Celek, where he is going right now.
While I predict the demise of the Giants’ passing game
in fantasy circles, I suppose it is only fitting I announce the
return of their running game. As I detailed above, New York’s
ground game has been a source of pride for some time, but 2009
saw the team do a complete 180-degree turn, something that occurred
in part due to an injury-ravaged backfield and uncharacteristically
poor line play. Brandon Jacobs dealt with a knee injury from Week
1 on last season and ran like it, often going down on first contact.
Ahmad Bradshaw was hampered by injuries to his ankle and both
feet and needed offseason surgery to correct those issues, returning
to the practice field for the first time in the middle of June.
In both cases, the duo showed they
were able to play in pain, a big deal for a pair of backs
who have yet to put together a single 16-game season between them
since they became prominent figures in the team’s running
game plans. We’ll probably have to wait until after the
season has started before we know just how much the line was at
fault for last year’s collapse in the run game, but if Jacobs
and Bradshaw can enter the season healthy, it’s a pretty
good bet that Jacobs will return to being a solid fantasy RB2
while Bradshaw flirts with top-end RB3 status.
Philadelphia
In the aftermath of the Donovan McNabb trade this offseason, many
have questioned whether Kevin Kolb – and his two career
starts – can fill the shoes of his predecessor. Here’s
what we know: despite HC Andy Reid’s best efforts, McNabb
was never going to be the consistent short-throwing strike machine
that a West Coast offense disciple like Reid wants – Reid
obviously believes Kolb is. Moreover, he inherits a supporting
cast that features his roommate on the road – Brent Celek
– along with two explosive WRs in DeSean Jackson and Jeremy
Maclin. What is harder to discern is…who benefits most from
Kolb? It’s probably a given that Celek will enjoy as much,
if not more, attention from Kolb as he got from McNabb, which
is saying a lot. But will the shorter, more accurate arm of Kolb
just lead to more catches, more opportunity or both for Jackson
and Maclin? I believe Kolb’s two starts (while subbing for
an injured McNabb) reveal little about what he means for the future
of his two wideouts. In Weeks 2-3 (Kolb’s starts), the Eagles
faced the Saints, who routed Philadelphia early on, forcing Kolb
to play catch-up most of the second half. The next week, he faced
the hapless Chiefs’ defense. At that point of the season,
Maclin was still a role player. In short, neither contest can
really tell us a great deal about what we can expect from Kolb
in a “normal” game.
At this very moment, I have a hard time believing Kolb will make
Jackson any more productive than he was last season. In fact,
with the slightly-built Maclin and Jackson now being asked to
run shorter routes (including ones over the middle of the field),
I could see both players becoming greater injury risks. Thus,
I would not want to count on Jackson as a WR1 in fantasy, nor
would I want to believe Maclin is ready to become anything more
than a steady WR3.
While one Philadelphia institution was getting shipped out of
town (McNabb), another one was asked to leave. The departure of
Brian Westbrook was music to the ears of LeSean McCoy owners,
who now believe the 22-year old will assume his mentor’s
role in the offense. As much as I liked the former Pitt Panther
as a value pick last year, I don’t like seeing his ADP being
so high this season (4.02). While there is definitely some Westbrook
in his game, McCoy still needs to show me he can handle the ball,
pick up the blitz and run in short-yardage situations better before
I put him too high on my board, even though OC
Marty Mornhinweg sees a much different back this offseason.
Mike Bell was brought in to take some of the pounding in short-yardage,
rookie Charles Scott has impressed in OTAs and it seems foolish
that Leonard Weaver would stay at FB full-time when he was the
most productive RB at times for the Eagles in 2009.
Michael Crabtree: On the verge of a 75-catch
season.
San Francisco
If it didn’t become apparent after opting to trade for Donovan
McNabb or passing on Jimmy Clausen multiple times during the draft
or the use of both first-round picks on offensive linemen, the
Niners’ brass believes Alex Smith is ready to fulfill the
promise that made him the No. 1 overall pick in 2005. Without
a doubt, he’s going to be helped by a number of key factors:
1) he will play in the same offensive system in consecutive years
for the first time as a pro, 2) the aforementioned upgrade on
the offensive line will make the running game that much better
AND give Smith more time and 3) he doesn’t have to look
over his shoulder at Shaun Hill anymore and perhaps, most importantly,
4) his supporting cast is among the best in the league, with everyone
from Frank Gore and Josh Morgan to Michael Crabtree and Vernon
Davis able to catch the ball and create a big play. OC Jimmy Raye
plans on using more
base sets this season – which is slightly discouraging
given Smith’s ability to operate effectively out of the
shotgun – but it is the command
and leadership that Smith is showing that has San Francisco
players and coaches so excited about this season. Generally speaking,
one of the biggest hurdles for any QB trying to establish himself
is to grab the respect of his team in the huddle and it appears
he has that now. Even though San Francisco expects to be a smash-mouth
football team again, it’s looking entirely possible Smith
is a potential low-end weekly starter or very good QB2 in fantasy
in 2010.
San Francisco wants
to move Crabtree into the slot…don’t worry, he'll
remain at his old split end on non-passing downs and will also
flanker as well when the team wants to do so. All this is being
done in an effort to exploit matchups and make sure the defense
cannot plan on the second-year WR remaining in the same spot play
after play. Let’s remember Crabtree did not practice with
the team in minicamps (injury) or training camp or most of the
first half of the season (holdout) and he still caught 48 passes
for 625 yards in just 11 games. It’s frightening to think
what he is capable of with a full offseason of practice and digesting
the playbook. With Gore and the running game capable of big things
and Davis drawing coverage his way down the middle of the field,
Crabtree could be on the verge of topping 70-80 catches and well
over 1000 yards this season. He’s a great WR2 fantasy pick
in the early-to-middle fourth round of 12-team leagues and should
be one of the better bets to meet and possibly exceed that tag
as the season progresses.
Seattle
Despite the additions of T.J. Houshmandzadeh and Golden Tate over
the past two offseasons, the Seahawks find themselves in a situation
in which they will need to count on another player – already
in-house – to be the primary receiver this fall. That player
appears to be John Carlson, who was somewhat of a disappointment
in 2009 despite finishing as a top-12 TE (or on the cusp) in most
leagues. Much of his lackluster production stemmed from one of
the worst offensive lines Seattle has fielded in years, which
required Carlson to stay in and block on running and passing downs.
With the additions of TEs Chris Baker and rookie Anthony McCoy,
the Seahawks appear to be willing to go with a lot of two-TE packages
in hopes to: 1) run the ball more effectively and 2) free Carlson
up to run routes while Baker or McCoy stays in to protect Matt
Hasselbeck. With Houshmandzadeh not a big-play threat and none
of the other WRs a likely go-to WR in 2010, much of Hasselbeck’s
focus in clutch situations will shift to Carlson, who finished
seventh in most PPR and non-PPR leagues as a rookie. Look for
the third-year TE to easily surpass his 2008 numbers (55-627-5)
this season.
Despite the solid job the Seahawks did in April’s draft,
it was going to be impossible for them to solve all of their problems
over a three-day period with college kids. One area in which they
rolled the dice with veterans was at RB in order to add to a roster
that really only boasted Julius Jones and Justin Forsett. While
Forsett showed his considerable ability in limited time in 2009,
Jones continued to frustrate Seahawk fans and his fantasy owners.
LenDale White, acquired in a draft-weekend trade from the Titans,
was automatically assumed to be the lead horse in the RB race
upon arrival, but his dismissal from the team in May changed all
of that. Leon Washington was also acquired over draft weekend,
but he can’t be counted on fully until he can confidently
go full-tilt in practice after suffering a compound leg fracture
last season. Thus, it looks like the underwhelming Jones will
have a fair shot at some decent playing time again, at least until
Washington proves his health or Forsett convinces the new regime
he can stand up to the punishment despite lacking ideal size.
Even ex-Redskin Quinton Ganther is in on this mess, as HC Pete
Carroll hinted to the Seattle
Post-Intelligencer that he would be in the short-yardage mix.
If you’ve concluded this is currently a mess of a backfield,
you’d be right. My favorite for fantasy value out of the
bunch is Forsett, but Washington has a great chance to lead a
committee here if he is a go by Week 1 (assuming he gets the benefit
of a full preseason).
St. Louis
It’s no secret that Steven Jackson is the Rams’ only
fantasy property worth caring about as we enter drafting season.
What is a bit more unknown is what his worth will be in fantasy,
with the most pertinent question being: “Can his back hold
up?” For those who haven’t been following him too
closely this offseason, Jackson underwent back surgery in early
April to repair a herniated disc he suffered in late November
2009. As is the case with all back surgeries, there are no guarantees
even though the prognosis was good and it is believed the “minor”
surgery won’t hamper his career in any way. Still, HC Steve
Spagnuolo wasn’t sure his stud RB was ready to run on solid
ground as of early June, so caution is definitely advised.
The problem with being cautious with Jackson, however, is that
he played through the injury and still performed admirably despite
the fact that opponents knew he was the only weapon. The second
year in OC Pat Shurmur’s system only figures to help him
and his supporting cast while No. 1 overall pick Sam Bradford
almost has to play better than any of the QBs St. Louis trotted
out onto the field last season (Marc Bulger, Keith Null, Kyle
Boller – highest QB rating of the three was Bulger’s
70.7). And let’s definitely not overlook the fact his offensive
line is better than average in the run game. Ideally, he’d
be a RB2 in fantasy most years, but with the market so thin on
actual every-down backs, Jackson has to be considered late in
the first round. But in a year where they are already so many
question marks besides elite players at their position (Jackson,
Ronnie Brown, Steve Smith, Vincent Jackson, Wes Welker –
just to name a few), Jackson is the riskiest considering the price
a fantasy owner will need to pay for him.
Tampa Bay
Perhaps the best story in the Bucs’ otherwise dreadful 2009
season was the resurgence (and continued health) of Cadillac Williams.
In the fantasy world, this is a RB that has been left for dead
a number of times since his captivating 1,000-yard rookie season
in 2005. Does the Cadillac story add another feel-good chapter
to the book this year? It
definitely looks possible. Consider for a second that Williams
finished 25th in PPR and 27th in non-PPR last season despite having
to cede free-agent signee Derrick Ward an average of 10 touches
per game. Add in the fact that he played on an offense that ran
through the entire depth chart at QB and ran behind an offensive
line that didn’t play nearly as well as it had in previous
years. Let’s also not forget that Tampa Bay was one of the
three teams that stupidly (let’s call it what it is) fired
the OC over a 10-day period just as the preseason was coming to
an end. And let’s not forget we haven’t even discussed
Williams’ long injury history that even threatened his career
at one point. While Williams has shown nothing but heart in his
career, Ward continued to disappoint the coaching staff this spring
by missing a few practices. All this is to say that as the Bucs
enter their first full season with OC Greg Olson and Josh Freeman,
Williams stands to be better this season than last because he’s
healthy, the team is somewhat stable and there is actually some
reason to be optimistic about the passing game this fall. Yes,
Williams remains a definite injury risk, but Ward is going to
have to step up his practice habits if he wants to remain in a
RBBC role.
While I fear using the word intriguing when it comes to a team
that will almost be forced to start two rookies at WR, it is certainly
interesting that second-rounder Arrelious Benn and fourth-rounder
Mike Williams will likely be in the lineup Day 1 barring injury
or a complete collapse in training camp. (To find out how I feel
about each player, feel free to review my
Rookie Impact article from two weeks ago.) Williams has apparently
taken the early lead in the race for Freeman’s attention
due to Benn’s ankle injury and a reported “better
understanding of the playbook”, but let’s just say
for now I have trouble believing that Williams is the type of
player who has matured quickly from all his college incidents.
Benn was one of the better run-after-catch WRs available in April’s
draft and that kind of skill usually endears a receiver to QB
and coaching staff. I can see Williams enjoying a lofty YPC, but
I expect Benn to be the more valuable WR in fantasy this simply
because he will be the most trusted Bucs WR. If there is one receiver
who may break up the Benn-Williams pairing in Week 1, it may be
former Eagle Reggie Brown, who is said to be enjoying a fine offseason.
Washington
Accustomed to winning the offseason most of the years, owner Daniel
Snyder’s team hasn’t spent nearly as much as it has
in past offseasons to receive a lot of publicity this time around,
be it good or bad. (Albert Haynesworth won’t let us forget
Washington, but a trade for Vincent Jackson would sure help Redskins’
fans forget the ill will he has caused.) Instead, the Redskins’
offseason has made some sense from a personnel standpoint at a
relatively low cost, outside of assembling a collection of RBs
that would have looked nice on a fantasy football roster in 2005
or 2006. The additions of OT Jammal Brown (via trade) and Trent
Williams (first-round draft choice) gives Washington the bookend
tackles it has lacked for years. As you may have assumed, this
is going to help a few Redskins become more fantasy-relevant than
they have been in the past. Chris Cooley is no stranger to TE1
status and it would not be shocking if he posted his best season
to date in 2010 with Santana Moss the only WR on the team that
can strike fear into a defense. But is it possible that Fred Davis
could enjoy more run in fantasy than just half a season? In fact,
the Redskins are “counting
on it”. The scenario isn’t hard to imagine when
Malcolm Kelly and Devin Thomas aren’t stepping up in practice
to take the WR2 role by the horns. I’m not suggesting that
Davis be drafted as a possible TE1, but keep him on your watch
list as a candidate for 30-40 catches if Kelly and Thomas continue
to wallow in mediocrity. That kind of production may allow him
to be useful as a bye-week fill-in or a high-upside TE candidate
in the event Cooley goes down again this year.
After referencing the 2005-06 fantasy football all-star RB selections
above, I would be remiss not to talk about them now. OC Kyle Shanahan
seems comfortable with Clinton Portis as the third-down back.
And apparently that is all we know, because in the Shanahan family
tradition, it’s not important to know who the RB1
is at this point of the season. But if we are to put any stock
in who is running with the first team in June practices, Portis
is for the most part but Larry Johnson is apparently the first
option at the goal line. If this arrangement sticks, the old
drill of not relying on a Shanahan RB will need to become habit
once again. Because the Shanahans (dad and son) like running the
ball and seem to trust Portis the most on third down, he has a
shot at low-end RB2 value, although he shouldn’t be counted
for anything more than RB3 production. On the other hand, LJ should
only be used to round out a fantasy owner’s bench at this
point. It’s hard to imagine Willie Parker finding any value
or even being on the team as the RB3 when that position is usually
asked to play special teams (something injury-prone Ryan Torain
has more experience at than Parker ever will). This isn’t
an avoid-at-all-costs backfield, but Washington RBs may have to
wait a year or two before they will have the horses up front to
post 5.0+ YPC like the running games Shanahan used to oversee
in Denver.
Suggestions, comments, musings about the article or fantasy football
in general? E-mail me.
|