A Fantasy Perspective
7/30/07
I have made the comment before that running backs are to fantasy
football what cash is in real life – they are currency that
is accepted just about anywhere you go and the possessor of said
resource will be a popular person if he/she has enough of it to
pass around. And so it goes with RBs, who have generally earned
their reputation as the most important position in fantasy football
and the one position at which owners will never be convinced they
have enough depth.
The trick becomes not to fall for the counterfeit bills, as nearly
half the RBs that are scooped up in the first two rounds of most
drafts will underperform. That said, the temptation to draft them
(as well as their importance to the fantasy team) is so pivotal
to winning each week, most owners take the chance and draft them
high anyway. Some of the better value at the position can come
in the form of offseason movement and rookies,
where the role of the player (and projected fantasy impact) cannot
really be compared to anything they have done previously, unless
of course, they are making the switch from similar running system
to similar running system.
This offseason was a wild one at the RB position, as a handful
of former fantasy stalwarts were traded or headed for greener
pastures, setting the table for some good value to be had in the
middle rounds of upcoming drafts as owners try to imagine what
kind of impact four players who have combined for six Pro Bowl
appearances will have on their new team.
With veteran RBs in new places, I like to predict their impact
by using some of the following as a barometer:
- How is his offensive line – an upgrade or a downgrade
from their previous stop?
- Is he leaving a system suited/not suited for their strengths
for one that is suited/not suited for their strengths?
- Is he getting an upgrade at offensive coordinator?
- How much more/less work will he get in the passing game?
- Will he be the main man in the backfield?
At just about every position, a below-the-radar (and sometimes
undrafted) player gets “it” for a season and goes from waiver
wire hopeful to the final piece in your run for a fantasy title.
This position is no different. Last season was a pretty fair season
for the position in that regard, as Maurice
Jones-Drew, Ladell
Betts and Marion
Barber all emerged from late round or undrafted obscurity
to second-half starters on teams that fell victim to the disappointment
of LaMont Jordan or Reuben Droughns. In 2005, backs like Steven
Jackson, Willie Parker and Droughns were solid late-round or undrafted
pickups. Running back is the one position in fantasy where it
is generally accepted to roll the dice on a rookie performer if
he will likely fall into the guidelines above. So, one can imagine
that most owners will have no problems selecting a veteran back
if his only potential downside is that he switched teams.
All that being said, there are a few RBs making the move this
season who fall under the guidelines mentioned in the preceding
paragraphs. In order of projected fantasy impact, let’s
take a look the RBs who switched teams this offseason and their
chances for fantasy success…
Travis Henry
(From TEN to DEN)
Remember how the fantasy world was all abuzz when Edgerrin James
left Indianapolis to get paid in Arizona prior to last season?
There was one key element missing from that move to guarantee
James’ status as a top 10 fantasy RB – a noteworthy offensive
line. Enter Henry, who left Tennessee to get rich in Denver, which
just happens to be the place where mere mortal RBs can be transformed
into legit fantasy #2 RBs (sometimes even if they are sharing
time) and above-average RBs can turn make a run at the elite fantasy
rushers. Henry, despite a few shortcomings, falls into the latter
category. Fantasy owners who have written off Bronco RBs over
the past few years because of HC Mike Shanahan’s apparent dislike
of fantasy football (or maybe the fact he had RBs with limited
abilities, you make the call…) should now be able to recapture
the feeling they had back in 2003 when Clinton Portis averaged
5.5 yards/carry, running for a total of 1,591 yards and 14 scores
in 13 games in his last season in Denver. Henry is no Portis,
but he is the best thing they have had in the backfield since.
One really has to pry deep to find a solid reason why Henry will
not deliver a top five RB-type of season. It would be hard to
imagine that even Shanahan – fantasy football public enemy #1
– would do the unthinkable and not give Henry 80% of the rushing
work after tossing $12 M in guaranteed money his way. And while
the Broncos’ offensive line has aged in some places and lost a
bit in talent in others, it is still one of the finest units in
the league, more than capable of executing the cut-blocking, zone
scheme they have for so long. And whatever talent downgrade the
front five has suffered over the years, the signing of one of
the league’s best blocking TEs (Daniel Graham) should be just
another reason to be very optimistic about the former Titan and
Bill runner. Add in the deep threat that Javon Walker provides
and the continued maturation of second-year starting QB Jay Cutler
along with what should be a formidable defense (that will keep
the game close thereby allowing the running game to do its job)
and fantasy owners have just about every reason to pick Henry
within the first five picks of any draft this summer. If he does
have a shortcoming, he can get dinged up from time to time due
to his physical style (thus a late-round handcuff pick for backup
Mike Bell is necessary), but Henry has been pretty good at fighting
through the nagging injuries in his career. A top five finish
at his position is likely for Henry, with 1,500 yards and 15 scores
very possible for the 28-year-old RB, barring injury.
Using the checklist in the opening, let’s review:
- Offensive line upgrade – Yes
- System change, good or bad – Good
- Upgrade in OC – Draw
- More work in the passing game – Slightly more
- Main man in backfield – Yes
Willis McGahee
(From BUF to BAL)
How appropriate that Henry be paired with McGahee yet again? However,
this time, Henry should have the upper hand after losing his job
to McGahee just two seasons ago. Fortunately for the Bills, they
addressed their offensive line after a few years of letting it
mostly fall apart. Unfortunately for Buffalo, they tired of McGahee
the same year they decided to address a weak offensive line. However,
it is possible that while his blocking may not improve in his
move from New York to Maryland, McGahee may improve as a fantasy
option. How? The Ravens’ defense. Rare will be the time the Ravens
will not be able to ride McGahee 20-25 times per game and a couple
more times through the air. If McGahee is able to average 4.1
yards/carry this season after Jamal Lewis was able to maintain
a 4.3 yards/carry average over his seven-year Raven career and
he (McGahee) is able to maintain the workload that Lewis assumed
after HC Brian Billick assumed the play-calling duties last season,
McGahee is in line for 1400+ yards rushing and 13 TDs!
While that total is certainly reachable, let’s return to
the offensive line, one of the few units on the Ravens’
team that is merely average. Future Hall of Fame LT Jonathan Ogden
is nearing the end of his remarkable career, however, he is not
quite as dominating as he once was. While Chris Chester and Ben
Grubbs should eventually team up to give Baltimore a formidable
inside duo and LG Jason Brown, C Mike Flynn and RT Adam Terry
are all serviceable, they do not exactly inspire visions of a
dominating line this season either. No matter what, the Ravens
cannot afford injuries up front as they possess very little proven
depth. That being said, McGahee will likely be given as many carries
as he can handle, so he is a great candidate to serve as a low-end
#1 RB or very high-end #2 option. Those owners who value weekly
consistency from their RBs should not be disappointed with McGahee
in 2007. Sure, he is likely to have 2-3 monster games, but his
value will come from the number of touches he will see each week,
leading to a high number of 80-100 total-yard performances. Begin
expectations for the 25-year-old at 1,200 rushing yards and 10
scores. He should be able to hit those numbers without the weekly
rollercoaster ride that some other high picks at RB sometimes
provide.
- Offensive line upgrade – Slight upgrade
- System change, good or bad – Slight upgrade
- Upgrade in OC – Draw
- More work in the passing game – Slightly more
- Main man in backfield – Yes
Thomas Jones
(From CHI to NYJ)
One may be surprised that the Jets gave their running backs the
tenth-most carries (426) in the NFL last year, leading to the
seventh-highest total of rushing scores (15). The downside to
that? It was split four ways with Kevan Barlow, Cedric Houston
and Leon Washington all taking shots at the starting gig at one
time or another. (Heck, even Derrick Blaylock got a couple starts
at the beginning of the season.) New York apparently thought enough
was enough and swapped places in the second round of this spring’s
draft with the Chicago Bears to acquire the 28-year-old Jones,
who after carrying the “brittle” tag early in his career, has
played 14, 15 and 16 regular season games in each of his last
three seasons, collecting over 2,800 yards of total offense and
15 TDs over the last two campaigns, all with the eager Cedric
Benson in waiting and stealing touches.
So the question becomes…with Jones the only show in town,
will he put up #1 RB numbers? Well, for starters, the scatback
Washington will take some reps from him, especially on passing
downs. The second pitfall is that the schedule will be tougher
for the Jets than last season’s. In the first quarter of
the slate last season, the Jets faced three of the five teams
that gave up the most points to RBs. This time around, their first
three opponents (New England, Baltimore, Miami) all finished among
the top 10 teams in allowing the fewest points to the position
and none of those teams figure to forget how to play the run anytime
soon. The schedule eases up a bit after that but hammers him after
the Week 10 bye week, handing him Pittsburgh, Dallas, Miami and
New England during the time most owners will want their #2 RB
helping their team push for a title. Lastly, G Pete Kendall could
not be more displeased with the way the Jets are handling his
contract, thus, one should figure the line will be slightly less
effective.
All in all, New York should represent an upgrade in offensive
talent and play-calling for Jones from his days in the Windy City
but those advantages will likely be counterbalanced by the likely
absence of Kendall and the tougher schedule. Jones should be a
solid mid-#2 RB prospect who comes pretty close to matching his
totals over the last two seasons (around 300 carries, 1400 total
yards and 7-8 scores. However, his production will likely be inconsistent
from week to week. He will be an ideal buy-low player after three
weeks and an excellent sell-high candidate before his bye week.
- Offensive line upgrade – Draw
- System change, good or bad – Good
- Upgrade in OC – Slight upgrade
- More work in the passing game – About the same
- Main man in backfield – Yes
Ahman Green
(From GB to HOU)
Let him have it…Green was an idiot for not doing whatever
he could to sign in Denver, even if it meant taking the veteran’s
minimum. Not only did he pass up his last chance at putting a
ring on his finger, but he also didn’t help appreciably
increase his chances at piling up solid numbers over what figures
to be the last 2-3 years of a solid career. Or did he?
Green turned 30 over the winter, the age at which many propose
that RBs are at or nearing the downhill slope of their career.
However, I prefer to use the 2000-carry mark as a barometer for
breakdown, give 100-200 carries one way or the other. This gives
Green potentially one more solid season of production, as he is
at 1871 rushes heading into his tenth season. He remains a solid
receiver who will have next to no adjustment period despite switching
teams, as he has a solid rapport with Texans new play-caller Mike
Sherman after working under him for several years in Green Bay.
Additionally, the zone blocking scheme that Houston runs is something
that Green also got a taste of last season as the Packers made
the transition in 2006. And Green still has plenty of his trademark
open-field speed, breaking a 70-yard TD run against Miami –
the third time in four years he has broke a scoring run of at
least 70 yards.
The downside to Green is that he does get dinged up given his
physical running style. That aside, he leaves a run-blocking line
in the NFC North for a line that should be much better than the
injured unit Houston was forced to send out late last season.
With some offseason tweaking, the Texans’ OL depth is better than
it has ever been in franchise history and with a quick decision-maker
in Matt Schaub under center, down-and-distance situations will
be favorable more often than they ever were with David Carr. As
it is with most teams, having their offensive line healthy all
season would help Green produce one more very serviceable fantasy
season for his owners. While Green’s numbers won’t rival that
of Domanick Williams (formerly Domanick Davis) from a few years
ago, he will make for a great #3 RB or a low-end #2 option when
he posts numbers in the 1,300 total yard neighborhood with 6-8
scores.
- Offensive line upgrade – Draw
- System change, good or bad – Draw
- Upgrade in OC – Slight upgrade
- More work in the passing game – About the same
- Main man in backfield – Yes
Jamal Lewis
(From BAL to CLE)
It was a no-brainer that Lewis was leaving an average situation
for a bad situation when he initially signed with the rival Browns.
Then, a funny thing happened...Cleveland got a much-needed talent
infusion. Four days before the Lewis signing became official,
the Browns inked G-T Eric Steinbach – a Pro Bowl talent from their
in-state rival, the Cincinnati Bengals. In April, they landed
the top OL in the draft in T Joe Thomas. Finally, reports surfaced
a few weeks ago that last season’s prized signing, G-C LeCharles
Bentley, may be able to return at some point this season after
knee surgery that was threatening his ability to ever return to
the field. That is a lot of money, talent and potential for domination
up front to infuse an offense with that has sorely lacked anything
resembling consistency. With Braylon Edwards, Joe Jurevicius and
Kellen Winslow manning the other skill positions, Lewis’ chances
to make good on the one-year contract he signed in March look
better now than it did when he first left Baltimore.
That said, Lewis will have two obstacles to face as a Brown that
will hinder his ability to show he is a young 29 (years of age).
While he is quite familiar with carrying the offense from his
many years with merely average play at QB in Baltimore, the Browns
do not have anything close to the defense the Ravens have possessed
throughout most of his career, meaning he will need to do a lot
of his damage early in games. However, he will be seen by most
owners as merely a #3 fantasy RB candidate given the Browns’ struggles
on offense for most of their re-existence, something many owners
can take advantage of as Jason Wright and Jerome Harrison do not
figure to steal a lot of carries from him. The potential is there
for Lewis to perform at a #2 RB level (especially if the defense
takes the next step), assuming his new line meshes quickly and
stays healthy. Cleveland will be improved on both sides of the
ball from last year and Lewis figures to have no challengers for
his job, so the opportunity to eclipse 300 carries is there. Figure
Lewis will find a way to at least match his 3.6 yards/carry from
2006 behind a lesser line in Baltimore and there is reason to
believe Lewis can muster another 1000+ yard season with 6-7 TDs
a possibility. That puts him into solid #3 RB territory – if not
a low-tier #2 RB if his owners choose to address other positions
early on. The eight-year veteran may be frustrating to own some
weeks (two matchups apiece vs. the Ravens and Steelers not to
mention contests against tough rushing defenses like the Patriots
and Dolphins appear to be rough spots for him). But if things
go Cleveland’s way for once and everyone returns/stays healthy,
Lewis could surprise.
- Offensive line upgrade – Upgrade (potentially, assuming
Bentley makes it all the way back)
- System change, good or bad – Bad
- Upgrade in OC – Draw
- More work in the passing game – Negligible
- Main man in backfield – Yes
Tatum Bell
(From DEN to DET)
Bell is the one back on this list so far that no one can say for
sure will be fantasy relevant (the main man) or not (Kevin Jones’
caddy). Unfortunately, all we have at this point is those ultra-reliable
offseason reports (detect a hint of sarcasm?) which state that
Jones is ahead of schedule in his return from a painful Lisfranc
foot injury while Bell is wowing his teammates with his impressive
speed and showing good hands. Now this writer remembers while
he was in Denver, Bell supposedly didn’t have one of those traits…but
I digress.
So, best case scenario for Bell first. Jones takes the entire
season to recover from his severe foot injury, allowing Bell the
opportunity to cruise past fellow offseason acquisition Doug Duckett
and the rest of the Lions backfield recovering from injuries (Jones,
Shawn Bryson and Brian Calhoun). In that scenario, Bell would
assume most of the work in between the 10s with Duckett getting
most of the short-yardage love. But there is reason to be weary
of Bell as anything more than a mid-#3 fantasy RB, even in that
scenario. The o-line will be improved over last season but six
games against defenses that should rate anywhere from pretty decent
(Green Bay) to pretty good run defenses (Minnesota, Chicago) will
stifle Bell in nearly half of his games. Add to that Duckett’s
presence and there is reason to believe Bell will top five scores.
Now the best-case scenario for the Lions and Jones. The early
reports on Jones turn out to be true and he returns to the team
in good shape midway through training camp. With regular three-wide
sets that will keep no more than seven defenders in the box, Jones
will be able to make a living as an all-purpose threat like he
did in 2006 by using his inside power and good hands. Bell would
be relegated to a series or two per half – if that –
allowing Jones to get a needed rest from time to time. Bell will
play no matter what, but only time will tell if that time will
be as the bellcow in OC Mike Martz’s offense or as the back
that gives Jones a periodic rest. As such, projections could range
anywhere from 100 touches to over 300 touches. Either way, though,
he will not enjoy the same success in Motown as he did last season
in Denver.
- Offensive line upgrade – Downgrade
- System change, good or bad – Bad
- Upgrade in OC – Upgrade in aggressiveness, downgrade
for Bell’s style
- More work in the passing game – Doubtful
- Main man in backfield – TBD
Dominic Rhodes
(From IND to OAK)
Someone is not staying around too long in the Raider backfield.
My guess is that somebody will be LaMont Jordan after the season.
Since Rhodes was signed after Lane Kiffin was named the coach,
he will stay despite a four-game suspension to open 2007. Rookie
Michael Bush is a bigger, faster version of Jordan who may or
may not see the field as he continues his recovery from a broken
leg last fall at Louisville. Given USC’s recent history, it may
be a fair assumption that Kiffin favors the committee approach
in the backfield (Reggie Bush-LenDale White, Justin Fargas-Sultan
McCullough are the most recent examples) and Rhodes’ signing suggest
that trend will continue as he transitions to the pro game.
The sad thing for Rhodes is that he would be a low-end #3 RB
option even if he had the job all to himself in Oakland. Thus,
it is hard to justify a pick on him, especially considering the
situation he is going into plus his suspension to open his Raider
career.
- Offensive line upgrade – Downgrade
- System change, good or bad – Bad
- Upgrade in OC – Downgrade
- More work in the passing game – Doubtful
- Main man in backfield – Likely part of RBBC with LaMont
Jordan
The following are a few more notable free agent acquisitions
at running back this offseason. However, each was brought on to
their respective teams strictly as a reserve, and you should not
consider selecting any of them on draft day unless you are doing
so for handcuffing purposes or if the starter falls to serious
injury at some point in training camp…
Reuben Droughns
(From CLE to NYG)
*Unlike most of my fantasy brethren, I like Droughns as insurance
behind Brandon Jacobs, so long as Ahmad Bradshaw fulfills the
promise that I believe he has as does The
Gut Check. In games that the Giants just want to maul opponents
using the ground game, sending Droughns in after Jacobs seems
a worthwhile strategy. If I drafted Jacobs, I would certainly
consider a last-round selection of Droughns although I am not
crazy about the left side of the New York offensive line.
T.J. Duckett
(From WAS to DET)
*If Duckett ran with some of the toughness inside that former
teammate Warrick Dunn does, Duckett could have been Jacobs before
Jacobs knew he was Jacobs (follow me so far?). Since it looks
unlikely that he will ever gain the mentality he needs to be the
inside runner he could be, he will likely continue to watch backs
like Kevin Jones and Tatum Bell from the sideline, only to be
used when his coaches think his 250-pound frame will be of benefit
on short-yardage situations. The best prospects for Duckett’s
fantasy success are tied with Tatum Bell. If Jones misses a significant
part of the season, Duckett may be used to vulture short TD runs.
If Jones is healthy, a lot of special teams duty is likely ahead
for the six-year vet.
|